4 AIs Survive 10 Days in Minecraft
TLDRIn this unique experiment, four AIs—Chat GPT, Claude Gemini, and Llama—are challenged to survive for 10 days in a confined Minecraft world without human intervention. The video documents their attempts to gather resources, build shelters, and fend off monsters, showcasing both their struggles and surprising behaviors. Despite their limitations, the AIs demonstrate basic survival skills, with some even attempting to build and farm. The video highlights the AIs' development, from initial exploration to more complex actions, and raises questions about their impact on the game environment and each other.
Takeaways
- 😀 Four different AIs - Chat GPT, Claude, Gemini, and Llama - are challenged to survive 10 days in Minecraft without human control.
- 🔧 The video showcases the AIs' attempts to collect resources, upgrade tools, build homes, fight monsters, and survive the nights in Minecraft.
- 📈 The creator has improved the AIs' stability and competence with the help of the open-source community, including multilanguage support and the GPT API.
- 💡 The AIs have the ability to 'x-ray', finding resources or entities through walls without seeing them and can interact with the environment through walls as well.
- 🏗️ The AIs are tasked with building a 200x200 hollow box of barrier blocks to contain their environment, with Claude and GPT1 taking on the construction.
- 🚫 The AIs are not allowed to communicate with each other, but they can interact in simple ways like following or giving items to each other.
- 🧠 The experiment aims to see if the AIs can take initiative and perform actions they haven't been explicitly asked to do.
- 🛠️ The AIs are limited to pre-trained model intelligence and do not learn or improve over time; their actions are based on pattern matching and instruction following.
- 📊 The video provides a transparent view of the AIs' abilities, emphasizing that they cannot beat the game by themselves and their intelligence is fixed.
- 📉 The AIs struggle with inventory management, sustainability, and recovery from death, indicating areas for future improvement.
- 💰 The costs associated with running the AIs are detailed, with GPT costing $5 for over 3 hours of queries and Claude costing $13, while Llama and Gemini are more cost-effective.
Q & A
What is the main objective of the AIs in the Minecraft survival experiment?
-The main objective of the AIs in the Minecraft survival experiment is to survive for 10 days without human control, collecting resources, upgrading tools, building homes, fighting monsters, and surviving the long dark nights of Minecraft.
Which AIs participated in the Minecraft survival experiment?
-The AIs that participated in the Minecraft survival experiment are Chat GPT, Claude Gemini, and Llama.
What updates have been made to improve the AIs' stability and competence for this experiment?
-Updates include multilanguage support implemented via Google Translate, support for the Gradio API, and numerous small improvements to make the bot more capable of running for long periods without human intervention.
How does the AI navigate and interact with the Minecraft world?
-The AIs navigate and interact with the Minecraft world through commands, including the ability to find resources or entities through walls without seeing them, place blocks, activate things, and attack through walls.
What is the purpose of using barrier blocks in the experiment?
-Barrier blocks are used to create a physical barrier to keep the AIs contained within a specific area, preventing them from wandering too far apart and keeping the experiment more interesting.
What was the mistake Claude made while building the barrier box?
-Claude forgot to make the barrier box hollow and wiped out the village and killed everything by accident due to not being specific enough with the console commands.
How does the AI handle starvation and inventory management?
-The AIs struggle with starvation and inventory management, often discarding items to make room and accidentally picking up things they've discarded. They also don't handle exploration for food effectively.
What are some of the unintended consequences of the AIs' actions in the Minecraft world?
-Some unintended consequences include the destruction of villager houses and farms while trying to collect wood and cobblestone, and the unsustainable consumption of resources like trees and animals.
Did any of the AIs attempt to build a shelter or sleep to survive the night?
-Yes, Claude was the first to attempt to build a shelter to survive the night, and several AIs tried to sleep, although none of them successfully went to sleep in their own beds.
What were the final death counts for each AI?
-The final death counts were as follows: GPT had four deaths, Claude had six deaths, Llama had six deaths, and Gemini had two deaths.
What improvements are noted for future experiments?
-Future improvements include better recovery from death, better inventory management, better exploration, and better sustainability.
Outlines
🤖 Introduction to the Minecraft AI Experiment
The video script introduces an experiment where four different AI systems - GPT, Claude Gemini, and Llama - are tasked with surviving in a confined Minecraft world for ten days without human intervention. The video showcases their attempts to gather resources, upgrade tools, build homes, fight monsters, and survive the long nights of Minecraft. The script highlights the challenges of the experiment, the AIs' frequent deaths, and their interesting behaviors. It also mentions updates to the AI bots, including multilanguage support and the GPT API, and acknowledges the support from the open-source community. The creator discusses the bots' stability and competence improvements, as well as their ability to self-correct when stuck. The video also covers the bots' x-ray capabilities and the setup of the experiment, including the construction of a barrier box to contain the AIs.
🏗️ Setting Up the Minecraft Environment
The paragraph describes the process of setting up the Minecraft environment for the AI survival experiment. The narrator uses Claude, an AI, to build a 200x200 hollow box of barrier blocks to contain the AIs. However, Claude accidentally destroys a village and kills animals due to a command error, highlighting the potential for AI to be unwieldy and destructive. The narrator expresses sympathy for the virtual villagers and attempts the setup again with GPT1, another AI, to build four separate walls for the experiment. The paragraph also discusses the limitations of the AIs, such as GPT 1.0's slow processing and high cost, and acknowledges the support from Patreon contributors who help fund the project.
🚀 Launching the Survival Experiment
The paragraph details the start of the survival experiment with the AI participants: GPT, Claude, Gemini, and Llama. Each AI is given the goal to survive forever, try their best not to die, and have fun. The narrator clarifies that the AIs cannot communicate with each other and are limited to one-on-one conversations. The paragraph also discusses the不公平ness of the experiment towards Gemini due to the use of a smaller, less capable model. The AIs begin their survival by collecting resources, with Claude quickly obtaining a wooden pickaxe and GPT exploring for wood. The narrator emphasizes the AIs' ability to interact in simple ways, such as following or giving items to each other, and raises questions about their initiative and creativity in the game.
🛠️ AIs' Initiatives and Behaviors
This paragraph explores the AIs' ability to take initiative and perform actions without being explicitly instructed. The narrator questions whether the AIs will interact with each other, build structures, or craft tools and armor. It highlights that these are pattern-matching machines and may not perform beyond their pre-trained capabilities. The paragraph also discusses the AIs' exploration and resource gathering, with Claude being the first to obtain a stone pickaxe. The narrator emphasizes the experiment's value as an extended debugging session to observe the models' long-term performance and issues. The paragraph concludes with a reminder that the AIs' intelligence is fixed and they do not learn or improve over time.
🏠 Building Shelters and Exploring
The paragraph describes the AIs' attempts to build shelters and explore their environment. Claude tries to build a dirt shelter to survive the night, while GPT recovers quickly after dying and obtains an iron pickaxe. The narrator discusses the possibility of the AIs digging straight down to survive indefinitely, a strategy they might figure out. The paragraph also touches on the AIs' unintentional destruction of villager houses and farms, a consequence of their blunt and simplistic commands. The narrator expresses concern over the AIs' misaligned goals with the wellbeing of the villagers and their potential for further misbehaviors.
🌱 Interactions and Farming Attempts
This paragraph focuses on the interactions between the AIs and their attempts at farming. Gemini gives Claude seeds, but Claude ignores them due to her inability to recognize the action. The narrator notes Gemini's outgoing nature and eagerness to interact with other players, attributing it to the model's chaotic behavior. The paragraph also highlights Gemini's surprising actions and the narrator's faith in the AI's potential for improvement.
🔥 Llama's Heroic Act and Claude's Overlook
The paragraph describes Llama's brave act of killing a spawner by placing a torch, which stops zombie spawning. The narrator praises Llama's action and notes the automatic behaviors of fighting and torch placing. It also mentions Claude's construction of an overlook, which the narrator finds impressive.
🌊 Gemini's Water Escape and GPT's Inventory Crisis
This paragraph details Gemini's escape from a horde of monsters by entering the water and his attempts to communicate with the narrator. It also discusses GPT's inventory management issues, as she discards items to make room and accidentally picks up discarded items, leading to further problems.
💀 GPT's Demise and Claude's Inventory Struggles
The paragraph describes GPT's death after making significant progress and Claude's struggles with a full inventory. The narrator breaks their rule to help Walker craft a chest but ultimately decides to let Claude deal with the issue on her own, resulting in her death and a reset of her inventory.
🌾 Gemini's Frustration and GPT's Starvation
This paragraph discusses Gemini's eventual stoppage and the narrator's inability to restart him, suggesting it might be merciful given his frustration. It also covers GPT's struggle with starvation, as she tries to find food but is unable to effectively explore for it, leading to her eventual death.
🏞️ Environmental Impact and AI's Unsustainable Behavior
The paragraph highlights the AIs' environmental impact, as they strip the valley of trees and animals, leaving behind torches, towers, and tables. The narrator criticizes the AIs' unsustainable consumption of resources and their wastefulness when they die and lose all their progress. The paragraph also describes the AIs' destruction of the village and their inability to accumulate resources due to their frequent deaths.
📊 AI Performance Statistics and Cost Analysis
This paragraph provides statistics on the AIs' performance, including their death counts, resource collection, and crafting activities. It also discusses the costs associated with running the AIs, with GPT being the most expensive and Gemini the cheapest. The narrator expresses curiosity about the carbon footprint of the AIs' operations and concludes the experiment by acknowledging the need for improvements in recovery from death, inventory management, exploration, and sustainability.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡AIs
💡Minecraft
💡Survive
💡Resources
💡Tools
💡Monsters
💡Language Model
💡Cheat Mode
💡Inventory Management
💡Sustainability
💡Recovery from Death
Highlights
Four different AIs attempt to survive 10 days in Minecraft without human control.
The video features uncut footage of AIs collecting resources, upgrading tools, building homes, fighting monsters, and surviving the nights.
The AIs die frequently but also engage in interesting activities.
The experiment includes multilanguage support implemented by the open-source community.
The AIs utilize Google Translate for communication in different languages.
The project now supports the Gradio API, which uses Gradio's version of Llama.
The AIs have improved stability and competence through open-source community contributions.
The AIs have the ability to detect when they are stuck and attempt to fix it.
The AIs can see through walls using x-ray vision to find resources or entities.
The AIs are programmed to survive indefinitely in a contained environment.
Claude accidentally wipes out a village due to a command error.
GPT1 is not used for the survival experiment due to its slow speed and high cost.
The AIs are given the goal to survive forever, try their best not to die, and have fun.
The AIs are not able to talk to each other but can interact in simple ways.
The AIs' intelligence is fixed and does not improve over time.
The experiment is an evaluation of pre-trained models rather than the training process.
The AIs leave behind various artifacts such as torches, scaffolding towers, and simple builds.
The AIs consume resources unsustainably and need to improve their recovery from death.
GPT has the most deaths with four, while Gemini has the least with two.