AI Anime Art Service Tier List

Sanime
18 Dec 202212:46

TLDRThe video script offers a detailed review of various AI anime art generation services, categorizing them into tiers based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters and their speed. The reviewer shares personal experiences with services like Starry AI, NightCafe, Dream by Womble AI, and Waifu Labs, highlighting the pros and cons of each. The discussion emphasizes the significant improvements in AI technology, particularly with Novel AI's stable diffusion model, which stands out for its consistency, speed, and user-friendly features, despite its high cost. The video also touches on the limitations of free services and the potential of new models like Akashi anime.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 The speaker is an artist who explores with AI art but doesn't consider themselves a master due to the individuality of artistic journeys.
  • 🖌️ AI art, particularly generating anime characters, is seen as a perk of the AI Revolution, with many services available for this purpose.
  • 🚧 The speaker has evaluated various AI anime art services, categorizing them into tiers based on their effectiveness in creating anime characters and other factors.
  • 🏆 Top-tier services like Novel AI's stable diffusion stand out for their speed and consistency across devices, offering a superior user experience.
  • 🚫 Lower-tier services struggle with speed and quality, often providing limited control over the generation process and yielding less satisfactory results.
  • 💰 The cost of using AI art services is a concern, with some services requiring payment for a limited number of images generated per month.
  • 💡 The speaker appreciates services that offer control over the generation process, such as Waifu Labs, which uses 'latent' features to modify images.
  • 🖥️ Some services are more suited for those with high-performance computers, while others are accessible across various devices.
  • 📈 The rapid advancements in AI art generation are highlighted, with significant improvements occurring in recent months.
  • 🎭 The speaker emphasizes the importance of quality of life features, such as saved images and stored prompts, for ease of use and recreation of ideas.
  • 💸 Token systems are common in AI art services, but their value and efficiency vary, with some services offering better value for money.
  • 📚 The speaker encourages exploration and experimentation with different AI art services, acknowledging that personal preferences and needs can influence the choice of service.

Q & A

  • What is the speaker's perspective on their own artistic abilities?

    -The speaker humbly acknowledges that they may not be the best artist out there, but emphasizes that everyone is on their own unique artistic journey.

  • What is the speaker's opinion on AI-generated anime art?

    -The speaker finds AI-generated anime art fascinating and considers it one of the great perks of the AI Revolution. However, they also recognize the limitations of certain AI art generation services in creating high-quality anime characters.

  • Which AI art services does the speaker criticize for their slow speed?

    -The speaker criticizes Starry AI, Night Cafe, Dream by Womble Ai, and Neural Love for their slow speed in generating AI art, especially when it comes to creating anime girls.

  • What are the speaker's thoughts on the 'Anime Does Not Exist' service?

    -While the speaker appreciates the custom training of 'Anime Does Not Exist' that allows it to create decent anime characters, they note that it has some classic AI limitations and is not very user-friendly for generating specific images.

  • How does the speaker describe Waifu Labs V2 compared to other services?

    -The speaker praises Waifu Labs V2 for its specialization in creating anime characters, the control it offers over the generation process, and its impressive speed, which they describe as 'the speed of thought.'

  • What is the speaker's main issue with Pixai, the AI art service in B tier?

    -The speaker's main issue with Pixai is the long generation time, which can take minutes and sometimes result in unsatisfactory images with AI artifacting, despite the high quality of the images it can produce.

  • What is the speaker's stance on the use of token systems in AI art services?

    -The speaker expresses dissatisfaction with token systems, finding them not always worth the investment, especially when the control and output are limited or not meeting expectations.

  • How does the speaker evaluate the 'Holara' AI art service?

    -The speaker is critical of Holara, noting that the free version offers little control and the paid plans are not a good value for the cost and limitations in image generation.

  • What are the key advantages of running AI art generation on one's own computer, according to the speaker?

    -The speaker highlights that running AI art generation on one's own computer, such as with the Sci-Fi Dream service, can be faster, cheaper, and offer more control over the images, as well as being unlimited if the user has a good computer.

  • Why does the speaker consider Novel AI to be the best option currently available?

    -The speaker considers Novel AI to be the best option due to its consistency, compatibility with various devices, fast image generation, and quality of life features like saved images and prompt storage in metadata.

  • What is the speaker's main concern about the cost of Novel AI?

    -The speaker's main concern about the cost of Novel AI is that it is expensive, especially for users who may want to generate a large number of images, and the cost can be a barrier for some users to fully enjoy the service.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Artistic Expression and AI Art Services Overview

The speaker begins by asserting their identity as an artist and addresses potential criticisms of AI art. They explain that AI art, such as generating anime characters, is a fascinating aspect of the AI revolution. The speaker has been tracking various AI anime art services and plans to review them, noting that some services excel at creating anime characters while others fall short. They emphasize the remarkable capabilities of Stable Diffusion, an AI model that stands out among the reviewed services.

05:01

📉 D-Tier AI Art Services: Limitations and Speed

The speaker discusses the D-tier AI art services, which include Starry AI, NightCafe, Dream by Womble AI, and Neural Love. These services are not adept at generating anime characters and are slow. The speaker shares their attempts to create a specific character using these services, highlighting the limitations and the token system, which they find not worth the investment. They contrast the D-tier services with the more recent and improved B-tier services.

10:01

🔄 B-Tier AI Art Services: Specialization and Innovation

The speaker moves on to the B-tier services, which are specialized in creating anime characters and offer better results than D-tier services. They discuss 'This Anime Does Not Exist' and 'Waifu Labs V2', noting their improvements and specialized training for anime characters. The speaker appreciates the control provided by Waifu Labs, which allows for modifications of image features. However, they also point out some limitations, such as the model's age and custom training, and the service's control interface.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI art

AI art refers to the creation of visual art using artificial intelligence. In the context of the video, AI art is used to generate anime characters and scenes, with the artist discussing various AI services and their effectiveness in producing anime-style images. The term is central to the video's theme as it explores the capabilities and limitations of different AI art generation platforms.

💡Stable diffusion

Stable diffusion is a type of AI model used for image generation that has been widely recognized for its high-quality outputs. In the video, the artist praises stable diffusion for its ability to create detailed and realistic anime characters, setting a high standard for other AI art services to meet. The term is significant as it relates to the comparison of different AI art platforms and their effectiveness in producing anime art.

💡Anime

Anime is a style of animation that originated in Japan, characterized by colorful artwork, fantastical themes, and vibrant characters. In the video, the focus is on the creation of anime-style art using AI, with the artist discussing their experiences with various AI services in generating anime characters. Anime is the central theme of the video, as the artist evaluates the services based on their ability to produce anime art.

💡Token system

A token system in the context of AI art services refers to a mechanism where users must purchase tokens to generate images. The more tokens a user has, the more images they can create. In the video, the artist critiques certain services for their token systems, arguing that they are not worth the investment due to the slow generation speeds or the quality of the output.

💡Waifu Labs

Waifu Labs is one of the AI art services discussed in the video, specialized in creating anime characters. It is noted for its use of a custom-trained generative adversarial network (GAN) and its ability to allow users some control over the generation process through 'latent' features. The artist's positive experience with Waifu Labs highlights the service's effectiveness in producing high-quality anime art.

💡Custom training

Custom training in AI refers to the process of fine-tuning a pre-existing AI model to perform a specific task or to better suit a particular style or requirement. In the context of the video, custom training is used to create AI models that are specifically designed to generate anime art. The artist appreciates services that have undergone custom training as they tend to produce more accurate and desirable anime characters.

💡Latents

In the context of AI art generation, latents refer to underlying features or characteristics of an image that can be manipulated to alter the final output. The artist discusses how Waifu Labs uses latents, which are DNA-like features, to give users more control over the generation process, allowing for adjustments in color, detail, and pose of the anime characters.

💡Price

Price in the context of the video refers to the cost associated with using AI art services. The artist evaluates the services not only on the quality of the art they produce but also on the value for money they provide. The discussion of price is crucial as it influences the artist's decision on which service to use and their overall satisfaction with the service.

💡Quality of life features

Quality of life features refer to aspects of a service or product that enhance user experience without necessarily being core to its primary function. In the video, these features include elements like saved images, stored prompts, and faster image generation speeds. The artist appreciates these features in Novel AI as they make the process of creating and recreating AI art more convenient and enjoyable.

💡Performance

Performance in the context of AI art services refers to how well and how quickly these services can generate the desired images. The artist evaluates the performance of different AI platforms based on their speed, consistency, and the quality of the outputs. Performance is a key factor in the artist's assessment of the services, as it directly affects the user experience and productivity.

💡Innovation

Innovation in the context of the video refers to the introduction of new technologies or methods that significantly improve the capabilities of AI art services. The artist discusses the rapid advancements in AI, such as the shift from StyleGAN 2 to newer models, and how these innovations affect the quality and speed of anime character generation.

💡User interface

User interface, or UI, refers to the design and layout of a service's software, including how easy it is to use and navigate. In the video, the artist critiques certain services for their UI, highlighting the importance of a well-designed interface in enhancing the user experience and making the process of creating AI art more efficient and enjoyable.

Highlights

The speaker is an artist who explores unstable diffusion, but does not consider themselves to be pursuing an unachievable skill.

The speaker acknowledges that everyone is on their own artistic journey and discourages negative comments about artists.

AI art, such as generating anime characters, is considered a great perk of the AI Revolution.

There are many ways to generate AI images, but the speaker has been tracking these services for years.

Some AI art generation services are slow and not particularly adept at creating anime characters.

The speaker lists their experiences with various AI anime art services, categorizing them into tiers based on their effectiveness.

Starry AI, NightCafe, Dream by Womble AI, and Neural Love are grouped together as services that are not great at creating anime girls and are slow.

The speaker praises the novel AI's model of stable diffusion for its advancements in AI art generation.

The tier system used by the speaker is based on the quality and speed of the AI services in generating anime characters.

Waifu Labs V2 is highlighted as a service that specializes in creating anime characters and offers more control over the generation process.

The speaker notes that Pixai, a free service running on a modified version of Novel AI stable diffusion, is in B tier due to its slower image generation speed.

Novel AI is praised for its consistency, speed, and quality of life features, placing it at the top of the tier list.

The speaker discusses the potential of running stable diffusion on one's own computer, depending on the hardware capabilities.

Holara is mentioned as a new AI service that shows promise but has a disappointing free version and a paid version that may not be worth the investment.

The speaker emphasizes the importance of the saved image and prompt storage feature in Novel AI for easy recreation of characters and concepts.

The cost of Novel AI is noted as a drawback, being expensive for unlimited generations.

The speaker concludes that Novel AI stands out due to its fast and consistent performance across various devices.