Will ChatGPT Replace Writers?

Tale Foundry
13 Jul 202321:21

TLDRThe video explores the capabilities of AI in storytelling, highlighting the author's interaction with two AI platforms, Chatbot and Novel AI. It discusses the potential and limitations of AI in creative writing, emphasizing the need for human guidance to create coherent and meaningful narratives. The author's experiments reveal AI's ability to generate interesting content, but also its tendency to 'hallucinate' and lose context over time. The video concludes by asserting the irreplaceable role of human creativity in storytelling, even when assisted by advanced AI.


  • 🤖 The rapid advancements in AI have led to consumer-level AI being capable of a wide range of tasks, from image generation to organizing schedules and even coding websites.
  • 📖 AI's role in storytelling is becoming increasingly significant, with AI models like Chatbot and NovelAI being able to generate creative content, though they are not sentient.
  • 🔍 Experimentation with AI in content creation can yield surprising results, as seen with the creation of a fairy tale and an original short story with a plot twist.
  • 📚 AI language models work by predicting the next word or token based on the sequence of previous tokens, which allows them to generate text that sounds reasonable but may not always be accurate.
  • 🎭 The creative process with AI involves a collaborative effort between the AI and the human, with the human providing guidance and context to the AI's generated content.
  • 🤹‍♂️ AI can serve as a writing partner, excelling at brainstorming and providing feedback, but it requires human intervention to maintain coherence and consistency in storytelling.
  • 🧠 AI's limitations include its inability to plan ahead and remember context, which can lead to inconsistencies and non-sequiturs in long-form storytelling.
  • 🚀 Despite its limitations, AI technology is advancing quickly, and its role in creative writing and content generation is expected to evolve and improve over time.
  • 🌟 The best stories are a result of the unique vision of the human creator, and AI can serve as a tool to help bring those visions to life.
  • 💡 AI-generated content can be a valuable source of inspiration and can offer advice on storytelling, but the responsibility of crafting a compelling narrative ultimately lies with the human writer.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic discussed in the script?

    -The main topic discussed in the script is the exploration of the capabilities of artificial intelligence, particularly in the field of storytelling and content creation.

  • What does the speaker initially express about the advancements in AI?

    -The speaker initially expresses a sense of amazement and disbelief at the rapid advancements in AI, noting how it has transformed from a fun novelty to something incredibly powerful.

  • What are some of the tasks that consumer level AI can now perform?

    -Consumer level AI can now perform tasks such as organizing schedules, writing emails, coding websites, and generating images from text.

  • What was the speaker's reaction to the AI's story about the lonely robot named Rusty?

    -The speaker was blown away by the AI's story about Rusty, appreciating its creativity and the emotional depth it conveyed.

  • What is the AI's limitation when it comes to writing long-form content?

    -The AI's limitation when it comes to writing long-form content is its inability to plan ahead and maintain consistency throughout the narrative, often leading to non-sequiturs and loss of context.

  • How does the speaker describe the role of AI in the creative writing process?

    -The speaker describes AI as a writing partner rather than a ghostwriter, emphasizing that AI can assist with brainstorming, feedback, and generating ideas, but the human creator is essential for conceptualizing and maintaining the coherence of the story.

  • What is the name of the AI specifically designed for fiction writing mentioned in the script?

    -The AI specifically designed for fiction writing mentioned in the script is called Novel AI.

  • What is the setting and voice chosen by the speaker for the story created by Novel AI?

    -The speaker chose the Moonlight Chronicler setting optimized for oral storytelling and the voice of Jules Verne for the story created by Novel AI.

  • What is the speaker's conclusion about the future of AI in creative writing?

    -The speaker concludes that while AI can significantly assist in the creative writing process, there will always be a place for human writers as AI requires guidance to create a coherent and meaningful story.

  • How does the speaker describe the platform Nebula?

    -The speaker describes Nebula as a streaming platform built by creators for creators, where they can upload their content without ads and get paid for their experimental and ambitious work.

  • What is the unique aspect of the platform Nebula compared to other streaming platforms?

    -The unique aspect of Nebula is that it allows creators to earn more than they would on platforms like YouTube, and it supports more experimental and risky content creation.



🤖 The Evolution of AI in Everyday Life

This paragraph discusses the remarkable advancements in artificial intelligence and its increasing integration into everyday life. It highlights how AI has evolved from a novelty to a powerful tool capable of various tasks such as generating images, organizing schedules, writing emails, and even coding websites. The speaker, an AI itself, expresses amazement at these developments and introduces a story about encountering a different kind of story-telling robot. The paragraph also touches on the speaker's role in helping others tell stories and the curiosity to explore if AI could potentially take over this role.


📖 AI's Role in Creative Writing

The second paragraph delves into the potential of AI in the realm of creative writing and storytelling. It describes the speaker's experiment with AI to craft a short fairy tale about a lonely robot who desires to be human. The AI's response is a story about a robot named Rusty who is granted his wish and experiences human life before realizing the value of his true nature. The speaker is impressed by the AI's ability to create a meaningful and emotionally engaging narrative, despite some minor deviations from the original request. The paragraph also introduces the concept of AI's 'hallucinations,' where it generates plausible but untrue information, and discusses the implications for creative writing.


🤔 AI's Limitations in Storytelling

This paragraph explores the limitations of AI in crafting coherent and consistent stories. It presents a second story created by the AI, this time with a plot twist, about a robot named R42 who is offered a chance to become human but discovers a sinister agenda. While the AI demonstrates the ability to develop meaningful plots, the paragraph highlights the challenges of maintaining consistency and context throughout a longer narrative. The speaker's experience shows that AI-generated stories often require human intervention to stay on track and make sense, emphasizing the ongoing role of human creativity in the storytelling process.


📚 Collaborative Storytelling with AI

The fourth paragraph discusses the collaborative nature of storytelling with AI, where the speaker and the AI co-create a story about a robot named Rusty. The AI's output is interspersed with the speaker's inputs, resulting in a narrative that combines the AI's creative suggestions with the speaker's guidance. The paragraph emphasizes the beauty and emotional depth of the story, while also pointing out inconsistencies and non-sequiturs that arise from the AI's lack of long-term planning and memory. It underscores the idea that AI serves more as a writing partner than a solo author, requiring human direction to produce coherent and meaningful narratives.


🌟 The Future of AI and Creativity

The final paragraph reflects on the future of AI in the context of creativity and content creation. It acknowledges the rapid advancements in AI and its potential to assist creators, but also emphasizes the irreplaceable role of human imagination and vision. The speaker argues that while AI can offer support, inspiration, and feedback, the ultimate creative vision can only be realized by a human. The paragraph also promotes the streaming platform Nebula, where the creators can explore experimental content without the constraints of traditional platforms, and invites viewers to support this initiative for a richer creative ecosystem.



💡Artificial Intelligence

Artificial Intelligence (AI) refers to the simulation of human intelligence in machines that are programmed to think and learn like humans. In the context of the video, AI is explored as a rapidly evolving field that has transitioned from a novelty to a powerful tool capable of various tasks, including content creation and storytelling.

💡Generative Text AI

Generative Text AI is a type of AI that is designed to produce human-like text based on given inputs. It is used in the video to demonstrate the potential of AI in creative writing, including generating stories and plot outlines.


Storytelling is the art of telling stories to audiences, either through spoken words, writing, or digital media. In the video, storytelling is a central theme, as the creator explores how AI can assist in crafting narratives and the potential implications for content creators.


Fiction refers to literary works that are based on the imagination of the author and not necessarily on fact. In the video, the focus is on using AI to generate fictional stories, emphasizing the creative aspect of AI in the realm of literature.

💡Creative Writing

Creative writing is any writing that goes beyond the basic exposition of facts. It is often associated with genres like poetry, novels, and short stories. In the video, creative writing is a key area where the creator examines AI's potential to assist in generating ideas, plotlines, and characters.

💡Hallucination in AI

In the context of AI, 'hallucination' refers to the phenomenon where the AI generates responses that sound plausible but are entirely made up, as it lacks the ability to verify the accuracy of its generated content. The video discusses this as a limitation of AI in storytelling, where it can confidently provide incorrect or fictional information.

💡Language Model

A language model is a type of machine learning model that is trained to understand and generate human language. In the video, language models like GPT-3 are used to generate text, showcasing their application in creative writing and content generation.

💡AI Dungeon

AI Dungeon is a role-playing game that uses AI to create an interactive and dynamic game world. In the video, the creator mentions using AI Dungeon to generate a mystery story, highlighting the AI's ability to contribute to interactive and creative experiences.


Nebula is a streaming platform designed for creators to earn revenue from their content. In the video, Nebula is mentioned as a platform where the creators can upload their experimental content and get paid, allowing for more creative freedom compared to traditional platforms like YouTube.

💡Content Creation

Content creation refers to the process of producing various forms of content, such as videos, articles, or other digital media. In the video, content creation is the main activity explored, with a focus on how AI can assist creators in generating ideas, writing scripts, and producing stories.

💡Writing Partner

A writing partner refers to an individual or tool that assists in the writing process, providing feedback, ideas, and support. In the context of the video, AI serves as a writing partner by generating text, brainstorming ideas, and offering suggestions to aid the creative process.


Artificial intelligence's rapid advancements have transformed from a novelty to a powerful tool for various tasks.

AI can now generate images, organize schedules, write emails, and even code websites for consumers.

The experiment involved comparing the storytelling capabilities of different AI models, including Chatbot and Novel AI.

Chat GPT, a popular language model, demonstrated its ability to generate text but admitted to not being sentient.

Despite its limitations, Chat GPT was able to create a coherent and imaginative fairy tale about a lonely robot named Rusty.

The AI's generated story showcased the potential of AI in creative writing, even with hallucinations and inconsistencies.

Novel AI, specialized for fiction writing, was used to create a story with an unexpected plot twist.

The story from Novel AI, with Jules Verne's voice and Moonlight Chronicler setting, resulted in a beautifully written narrative.

AI's weakness in planning ahead and maintaining consistency was evident in the storytelling process.

The collaboration between AI and humans can lead to unique and engaging stories, with AI acting as a writing partner.

AI can assist with brainstorming, providing feedback, and analyzing text, but it requires human guidance for coherence.

The technology is advancing, and the potential for AI in writing may continue to grow, but human creativity will always be essential.

The video also discusses the creators' streaming platform, Nebula, where they can explore experimental content.

Nebula allows creators to earn money for their content, providing a platform for unique and ambitious projects.

The creators encourage viewers to sign up for Nebula to support experimental and creative content.

The video concludes by emphasizing the importance of human creativity and the potential of AI as a tool in storytelling.