illustrator gives tips on how to tell if art is AI generated

venonet
14 Jan 202418:31

TLDRIn the video, artist Patrick, also known as Veno, discusses the challenges of distinguishing AI-generated art from human-created art. He shares his methods for identifying AI art by examining the volume of output, the lack of understanding in details such as sword handles and armor patterns, and the repetitive nature of AI's rendering. Patrick emphasizes the importance of supporting real artists and their creative process, expressing concern that the rise of AI art may undermine the value and legitimacy of human-made artwork.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 **Volume of Output**: AI artists tend to produce and post a high volume of artwork, which can be a telltale sign of their identity.
  • πŸ” **AI Spew**: AI-generated art often contains excessive and noisy details, especially in decorative or intricate parts, which can appear uncharacteristic and odd.
  • πŸ—£οΈ **Lack of Artistic Intent**: AI art may lack the intentionality and understanding behind human artistry, such as the proper rendering of folds in clothing or the accurate depiction of objects.
  • πŸ‘₯ **Repetitive Detail**: AI struggles with repetitive elements, often over-emphasizing or repeating patterns without a clear purpose or variation.
  • 🌐 **Mixed Style Usage**: AI-generated images may exhibit a blend of styles that don't naturally complement each other, resulting in an inconsistent and jarring visual effect.
  • πŸ‘οΈ **Detail Resolution**: AI art can have abrupt shifts in detail resolution, with some areas being overly detailed and others too smooth or flat.
  • 🎭 **Subject Matter**: AI tends to favor certain subject matters like exaggerated or fantastical themes, often lacking depth or a substantive story behind them.
  • πŸ‘€ **Creator's Profile**: Checking an artist's profile and body of work can reveal consistencies in style and progression over time, which is less likely with AI-generated content.
  • πŸ•°οΈ **Time and Progression**: Human artists show a clear progression in their skills and style over time, whereas AI output may not reflect this natural development.
  • πŸ’‘ **Impact on Art Culture**: The rise of AI art may lead to a devaluation of human artistic efforts and a potential loss of respect for genuine artistry.

Q & A

  • How long has Patrick, also known as Veno, been studying art?

    -Patrick has been studying art for a significant period, totaling almost seven years, with a particular focus on digital painting which he started during his sophomore year in college, amounting to approximately four or five years.

  • What is the main frustration Patrick expresses about AI art?

    -Patrick expresses frustration over the online debate concerning the authenticity of AI-generated art versus human-created art. He is concerned about the misattribution and confusion between AI and non-AI art, and the devaluation of human artistry that results from this.

  • What is the first characteristic Patrick mentions to identify AI art?

    -The first characteristic Patrick mentions is the high volume of output. AI artists tend to post a large number of artworks, which would typically take a human artist weeks or months to complete, on a daily or weekly basis.

  • What does Patrick refer to as 'AI spew'?

    -'AI spew' is a term Patrick uses to describe the chaotic and nonsensical details often found in AI-generated art. It refers to the odd, noisy, and unsymmetrical elements that lack the intentionality and coherence of human artistry.

  • How does Patrick suggest determining the authenticity of an artwork?

    -Patrick suggests examining the artist's profile and the volume and consistency of their work as a key indicator of authenticity. He also advises looking for inconsistencies in style, repetitive details, and elements that lack a clear purpose or understanding of the subject matter.

  • What common themes does Patrick notice in AI-generated art?

    -Patrick notes that AI-generated art often features themes such as 'booby women', 'beautiful women', 'random badass rebels', and 'weird Sci-Fi fantasy art'. These themes are prevalent due to the AI's tendency to generate popular and sensational content without a deeper understanding or creative intention.

  • What is Patrick's concern about the impact of AI art on the art world?

    -Patrick is concerned that AI art could lead to a devaluation and lack of respect for human artists and their work. He fears that the ease with which AI generates art might cause people to doubt the legitimacy and effort behind original, human-created pieces.

  • How does Patrick describe the difference between AI and human artistry?

    -Patrick describes human artistry as having intention, understanding, and a personal style that develops over time. In contrast, AI art often lacks these qualities, displaying a sense of soullessness and a lack of genuine interest or understanding of the subject matter.

  • What advice does Patrick give to those interested in identifying AI art?

    -Patrick advises individuals to carefully examine the artist's profile and output, look for inconsistencies and high volumes of work, and be aware of the common themes and stylistic issues typical of AI-generated art. He also emphasizes the importance of recognizing the time and effort that goes into human-created art.

  • What is Patrick's personal experience with art and how does he showcase it?

    -Patrick has been creating art for a long time, starting with his first digital painting in 2018. He showcases his work on Instagram, where he has a diverse portfolio including comics, design work, and various experiments in style. His work demonstrates a consistent evolution and personal touch that sets it apart from AI-generated content.

  • How does Patrick feel about the future of AI in the context of art?

    -Patrick is apprehensive about the future impact of AI on the art world. He worries that AI could lead to a loss of respect and recognition for human artists, and that the genuine passion and effort behind creating art could be undermined by the ease and volume of AI-generated content.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Identifying AI Art Through Output Volume and Quality

The speaker, Patrick, an experienced digital artist, discusses the characteristics of AI-generated art. He emphasizes that AI artists produce a high volume of work, often posting daily or weekly, which would be impossible for a human artist to match. He points out that even as AI technology improves, the sheer quantity of output will remain a giveaway. Patrick also introduces the term 'AI spew,' describing it as a chaotic and unstructured mess of details, particularly evident in the decorative aspects of objects like swords. He argues that AI-generated art lacks the intentionality and understanding of a human artist, resulting in odd and inconsistent designs.

05:01

πŸ–ŒοΈ Distinguishing AI Art by Style and Detail Discrepancies

Patrick continues his analysis by explaining how to identify AI art through style inconsistencies and a lack of understanding of mechanical or organic forms. He uses examples from the AI-generated images, pointing out the oddities in rendering and the lack of coherence in the depiction of objects like a machine or armor. He also addresses the common issue of AI struggling with repetitive details, leading to excessive and meaningless patterns. Patrick notes that AI art often relies on viewers' lack of understanding of the world, using this to create pieces that appear detailed but lack substance.

10:03

πŸ‘€ Subject Matter and Style Telltale Signs of AI Art

In this paragraph, Patrick talks about the common subject matters that AI art tends to focus on, such as exaggerated portrayals of women, sci-fi and fantasy themes, and seemingly random or rebellious art. He critiques the lack of substance and originality in these AI-generated images, often just mimicking the style without any meaningful content or story behind them. Patrick also highlights the issue of AI art lacking consistency in lighting and rendering, resulting in jarring effects and an unnatural blend of styles. He stresses the importance of checking an artist's portfolio to see if the work could reasonably be produced by a single person, as AI can produce a vast amount of work in a short time.

15:04

πŸ’‘ The Impact of AI Art on the Art Community

Patrick concludes his discussion by sharing his personal art journey and emphasizing the importance of genuine artistic practice. He expresses concern that AI art, created by those who may not fully understand or appreciate the art form, could undermine the value and respect for authentic artwork. Patrick fears that the public may begin to doubt the legitimacy of art created by revered artists, as AI art's soulless and derivative nature could blur the lines between real and AI-generated art. He calls for a recognition of the hard work and passion behind true art and laments the potential loss of respect for the artistry of masters in the face of AI's influence.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘Digital Painting

Digital Painting refers to the creation of artwork using digital tools and software, as opposed to traditional mediums like canvas and paint. In the video, the speaker has been studying digital painting for a significant amount of time, indicating their expertise and passion for this form of art. This is central to the video's theme as it contrasts the personal journey and skill development in digital art with the impersonal output of AI-generated art.

πŸ’‘AI Art

AI Art, or Artificial Intelligence Art, refers to artwork that is created with the assistance of or entirely by artificial intelligence. The video discusses the辨别 AI-generated art from human-created art, emphasizing the differences in style, output volume, and the emotional and creative connection present in human art that is often lacking in AI-generated pieces.

πŸ’‘Output Volume

Output Volume refers to the quantity of work produced by an artist or, in this context, an AI. The video highlights that AI artists tend to have a much higher output volume, often posting numerous pieces in a short span of time, which would be unrealistic for a human artist. This is used as a key indicator to distinguish AI art from human-made art.

πŸ’‘AI Spew

AI Spew is a term used in the video to describe the chaotic and nonsensical details often found in AI-generated art. It refers to the cluttered, noisy, and unstructured elements that lack the intentionality and coherence of human artistry. This concept is used to illustrate the limitations of AI in replicating the thoughtful and purposeful design of human-made art.

πŸ’‘Repetition of Detail

Repetition of Detail refers to the AI's tendency to repeat certain patterns or elements in a piece of art, often without understanding the context or purpose of these details. This repetition is a sign of the AI's lack of comprehension of the subject matter and its inability to create art with intentionality and variation, as a human artist would.

πŸ’‘Mixed Media

Mixed Media is a term used in art to describe the combination of different artistic media or materials in a single artwork. In the video, the speaker discusses how some people mistake AI-generated art for mixed media due to the varied styles and levels of detail present. However, the speaker clarifies that true mixed media art has a purposeful blend of styles and techniques, unlike the disjointed and inconsistent output of AI.

πŸ’‘Subject Matter

Subject Matter in art refers to the content or topic of an artwork. In the context of the video, the speaker discusses how AI tends to favor certain subject matters, such as depictions of women or science fiction themes, often lacking depth or substance behind these images. This highlights the AI's limitation in creating meaningful and culturally rich content.

πŸ’‘Style Consistency

Style Consistency refers to the uniformity and coherence in an artist's work, reflecting their unique approach and creative voice. The video emphasizes the importance of style consistency as a distinguishing factor between human and AI-generated art, as AI often exhibits a disjointed and inconsistent style due to its lack of a personal creative vision.

πŸ’‘Artistic Intent

Artistic Intent refers to the purpose, meaning, or message behind an artwork, which is often a reflection of the artist's thoughts, emotions, and experiences. The video underscores the absence of genuine artistic intent in AI-generated art, as AI lacks the personal connection and understanding of the world that human artists bring to their work.

πŸ’‘Cultural Impact

Cultural Impact refers to the influence that a particular phenomenon or development has on society's values, behaviors, and norms. In the video, the speaker expresses concern about the cultural impact of AI art, fearing that it may undermine the value and legitimacy of human-made art by creating doubt and confusion about the authenticity of creative works.

πŸ’‘Art Appreciation

Art Appreciation is the recognition and enjoyment of creative expression in various forms of art. The video discusses the potential negative effects of AI art on art appreciation, as the ease and volume of AI-generated content may lead to a devaluation of the skill, effort, and creativity involved in traditional art-making processes.

Highlights

Patrick, also known as Veno, is an artist with seven years of studying digital painting and art.

He started painting digitally during his sophomore year in college, which was around five years ago.

Patrick expresses frustration over the online debate of whether AI-generated art is 'real' art.

The best tip to identify AI art is to look at the volume of output; AI artists post a high volume of artwork regularly.

A characteristic of AI art is the 'AI spew', where the artwork has a noisy, unsymmetrical, and odd organic appearance.

AI-generated art often lacks the understanding of how elements in a piece should align or interact, such as a sword handle not fitting the sword properly.

AI-generated art tends to over-detail and render lines and folds in an unrealistic way, such as making cloth folds look like boulders.

AI struggles with repetitive details, often repeating patterns without understanding their purpose or how they should bend or protect.

Mixed media usage is often mistaken for AI art, but the difference lies in the details and the style consistency.

AI-generated art often has a lack of understanding of mechanical elements, making them appear oddly organic and misshapen.

AI-generated art tends to focus on popular and superficial themes, such as 'booby' women or generic sci-fi characters.

AI-generated art lacks substance and a specific story or reason behind the artwork, often appearing as just an idea without depth.

Patrick emphasizes the importance of checking an artist's profile and their body of work to understand the context and legitimacy of their art.

He shares his own art journey and development over the years, showing consistency in style and the human aspect of growth in an artist's work.

Patrick worries that AI art will lead to a devaluation of real artwork and a lack of respect for true artists and their mastery.

The lasting impact of AI art might be the doubt it creates about the legitimacy of real artists' work.

Patrick's main concern is that AI art, created by those not passionate about the arts, feels soulless and cheapens the value of art.

He argues that AI art does not democratize art but rather removes the respect and value people have for true artistic creation and culture.