Midjourney vs Adobe Firefly 3 | Ultimate Comparison (Best AI Image Generator)

AI Catalyst
10 May 202408:12

TLDRIn this comparison, Adobe's latest AI image generator, Firefly Image 3, is pitted against Midjourney V6 to determine the superior AI for image generation. Firefly 3, currently in beta, introduces advanced features like structure and style references, promising photorealistic results and a variety of styles. Both AIs are tested across different artistic styles, with Midjourney V6 scoring higher in photo realism, character portrayal, and minimalist logo creation. Firefly 3 struggles with anime style but performs well in photo realism. Midjourney V6, with its specialized anime model, excels across all categories, ultimately winning the comparison with a score of 8 to 3. While Firefly 3 shows significant progress, it has yet to match Midjourney's capabilities. The video concludes by suggesting the combination of Midjourney with Photoshop's generative features for advanced image editing.

Takeaways

  • 🚀 Adobe has released a new version of their AI image generator, Firefly Image 3, aimed at improving image quality and detail with advanced stylization options.
  • 🔍 Firefly 3 offers features like structure and style reference, similar to Midjourney, to align created images closely with the original concept.
  • 🎨 Firefly 3 promises enhancements in rendering photorealistic quality, with improved lighting, positioning, and a variety of styles for illustrations and icons.
  • 📅 Firefly Image 3 is currently in beta and accessible through the Firefly web application, with both free and paid plans available.
  • 🆚 A comparison between Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3 was conducted using the same prompts to create images in different artistic styles.
  • 📌 In photorealism, both Firefly and Midjourney performed well, resulting in a tie for this category.
  • 🤔 Both generators struggled with portraying multiple characters, but Midjourney generated more accurate characters with fewer artifacts.
  • 🎭 Both Firefly and Midjourney captured the pop art aesthetic and style effectively, leading to another tie.
  • 🖼️ Midjourney V6 outperformed Firefly 3 in creating minimalist logos, earning it a point in this category.
  • 🎭 Firefly 3 failed to create anime style images, whereas Midjourney, even with its standard model, delivered great results.
  • 📸 Midjourney was more convincing in achieving the sepia effect and the feel of an old photo, securing the final point.
  • 🏆 Midjourney won the comparison with a score of 8 to 3, showcasing its strength in image generation.

Q & A

  • What is the latest iteration of Adobe's AI image generator called?

    -The latest iteration of Adobe's AI image generator is called Firefly Image 3.

  • What are the new capabilities introduced in Firefly Image 3?

    -Firefly Image 3 introduces capabilities like structure reference and style reference, providing tools to quickly create images that closely align with the original concepts without extensive trial and error.

  • How can users access Firefly Image 3?

    -Firefly Image 3 is currently available in beta and can be accessed through the Firefly web application with options for both free and paid plans. It is also available in the better version of Adobe Photoshop.

  • What is the scoring system used to compare Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3?

    -The scoring system involves creating images in different artistic styles using the same prompt for both Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3. Each generator gets points based on their performance, and the one with the highest total score is the winner.

  • How did Firefly Image 3 perform in the photo realism style?

    -Firefly Image 3 delivered surprisingly convincing and photo-realistic results, closely matching Midjourney V6 in this category, resulting in a tie.

  • What was the point of contention between Firefly and Midjourney when portraying multiple characters?

    -Both Firefly and Midjourney struggled with portraying multiple characters, but Midjourney managed to generate characters more accurately with fewer artifacts and old details, earning it the point in this category.

  • Which AI image generator is better for creating pixel art?

    -Midjourney V6 is better for creating pixel art, as Firefly Image 3 still cannot create pixel art like previous versions of Midjourney.

  • How did Adobe Firefly 3 perform in creating minimalist logos for brands?

    -Midjourney V6 performed better when it came to creating minimalist logos for brands, earning it a point in this category.

  • What is the special model for anime style in Midjourney?

    -Midjourney has a special model for anime style called 'nii', which delivers great results even with the standard model.

  • How did the two generators perform in creating a sepia effect and the feel of an old photo?

    -Both Midjourney and Firefly delivered very photo-realistic results, but Midjourney was more convincing with the sepia effect and overall feel of an old photo, earning the final point.

  • Who was the winner of the comparison between Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3?

    -The winner of the comparison was Midjourney V6, with a score of 8 to 3.

  • What is the current status of Firefly Image 3 in terms of its capabilities compared to Midjourney?

    -Firefly Image 3 shows good progress over Firefly 2 but can't quite match Midjourney in terms of image generation yet. However, it can produce convincing photorealistic images and is best used in Adobe Photoshop for editing.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Firefly AI vs. Mid Journey: Image Generation Showdown

Adobe's latest AI image generator, Firefly Image 3, is compared with Mid Journey V6. The comparison is based on their ability to generate images in different styles using the same prompt. Firefly 3 introduces new features like structure and style reference, promising better photorealistic results with improved lighting and positioning. Both AIs are tested on various styles, including photo realism, pop art, pixel art, minimalist logos, anime style, and old photo effects. Firefly 3 shows significant progress but cannot yet outperform Mid Journey in overall image generation. However, it excels in creating convincing photorealistic images and is best utilized within Adobe Photoshop for further editing.

05:02

🏆 Mid Journey Wins the AI Image Generation Battle

In the detailed comparison, Mid Journey V6 outperforms Firefly Image 3 in several categories. It achieves better results in creating minimalist logos, anime-style images, and old photo effects. While Firefly 3 makes a strong attempt, it falls short in the anime style category and does not yet support pixel art creation. Mid Journey V6, with its special model for anime, 'nii,' and its convincing sepia effect, secures a higher score. The final tally is 8 to 3 in favor of Mid Journey. The video concludes with a mention of Domo AI, another AI tool for creating artwork, and an invitation to explore its capabilities through a provided link.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI image generator

An AI image generator is a software application that uses artificial intelligence algorithms to create images based on user inputs. In the context of the video, Adobe's Firefly AI and Midjourney are compared as examples of AI image generators. They are designed to improve the quality and detail of generated images, offering advanced options for stylization and photorealistic results.

💡Photo realism

Photo realism refers to the quality of an image that closely resembles a photograph. It is a style that is highly valued in AI image generation for its ability to create convincing and lifelike visuals. The video compares the photorealistic capabilities of Firefly 3 and Midjourney, with both striving to produce images that look like they were taken with a camera.

💡Structure reference

Structure reference is a feature in AI image generation that helps to guide the creation of images by providing a structural framework. It ensures that the generated images have a coherent and logical composition. In the video, Firefly 3 is noted to have this capability, which aids in aligning the generated images closely with the original concepts.

💡Style reference

Style reference is a tool within AI image generators that allows users to specify the artistic style they want for their images. This feature helps to create images with a consistent and desired aesthetic. The video mentions that both Firefly 3 and Midjourney provide style reference tools to achieve stylized images.

💡Rendering

Rendering in the context of image generation refers to the process of generating an image from a digital model or description. It involves calculating and displaying the image's pixels to create a final product. The video discusses improvements in rendering, particularly in terms of photographic quality, lighting, and positioning.

💡Pop art

Pop art is an art movement that emerged in the 1950s and draws from popular culture and mass media. It is characterized by its use of bright colors, bold lines, and recognizable imagery. In the video, the AI image generators are evaluated on their ability to create images in the pop art style, which requires capturing the aesthetic and style of this art form.

💡Pixel art

Pixel art is a form of digital art where images are created on the pixel level, often resulting in a low-resolution, blocky appearance that is reminiscent of early video games. The video notes that neither Firefly 3 nor Midjourney's previous versions could create pixel art effectively, but there is an expectation that future versions might improve in this area.

💡Minimalist logos

Minimalist logos are design elements that use simplicity and the bare minimum of details to convey a brand's identity. They are characterized by clean lines and a focus on essential elements. The video compares the generators' ability to create minimalist logos, with Midjourney being favored for its effectiveness in this style.

💡Anime style

Anime style refers to the visual art style often associated with Japanese animation and comics. It is characterized by colorful, detailed illustrations and distinctive facial features. The video discusses the generators' performance in creating anime-style images, with Midjourney having a special model for this style and outperforming Firefly 3.

💡Sepia effect

The sepia effect is a color grading technique that gives images a brownish tone, reminiscent of old photographs. It is used to evoke a sense of nostalgia or to make an image appear vintage. In the video, the AI generators are compared based on their ability to apply a convincing sepia effect to their generated images.

💡Adobe Photoshop

Adobe Photoshop is a widely used image editing software that offers a range of tools for manipulating and enhancing digital images. The video mentions that Firefly 3 is available in a better version of Adobe Photoshop, suggesting that the software can be used to further edit and refine the images generated by Firefly 3.

Highlights

Adobe released the latest iteration of their AI image generator, Firefly AI, known as Firefly Image 3.

Firefly Image 3 aims to improve image quality and detail with advanced stylization options.

Firefly 3 introduces capabilities like structure reference and style reference, similar to Midjourney.

This version of Firefly promises better lighting, positioning, and a rich array of styles.

Firefly Image 3 is available in beta through the Firefly web application with both free and paid plans.

Firefly Image 3 is also available in the advanced version of Adobe Photoshop.

A comparison will be made using the same prompt for Midjourney V6 and Adobe Firefly 3.

The first style compared is photo realism, where both generators performed well.

Midjourney V6 is known for exceptional photo realism, but Firefly closely matches it.

Both Firefly and Midjourney struggle with portraying multiple characters.

Midjourney managed to generate characters more accurately with fewer artifacts.

Both generators nailed the pop art aesthetic and style.

Domo AI is introduced for creating stunning artwork with various features.

Firefly 3 still can't create pixel art, unlike Midjourney V6 which does a good job.

Midjourney is better at creating minimalist logos for brands.

The anime style is a miss for Firefly, while Midjourney has a special model for it.

Both generators handled the sepia effect and old photo feel well, but Midjourney was more convincing.

Midjourney won the comparison with a score of 8 to 3.

Firefly Image 3 shows good progress but can't quite match Midjourney in image generation yet.

Firefly is best used in Adobe Photoshop for editing and refining images.

Midjourney can be combined with Photoshop's generative features to edit and clean up images.