Midjourney V6 vs Stable Diffusion 3 | Ultimate Comparison (Best AI Image Generator)

AI Catalyst
8 Jul 202408:27

TLDRIn this comparison, Midjourney V6 and Stable Diffusion 3 battle it out as the best AI image generator. Both are tested across various styles with the same prompts, and points are awarded based on performance. While Stable Diffusion 3 has improved in certain areas, Midjourney V6 excels in photorealism and sketching, leading to a final score of 83 in its favor. Stable Diffusion is lauded for being free, but Midjourney offers more tools and less censorship, making it the superior choice for now.

Takeaways

  • 🌟 Midjourney V6 is considered the best AI image generator, but Stable Diffusion 3 is a free alternative that's recently available for download and local use.
  • 🎨 In photorealism, Stable Diffusion 3 has not shown significant improvement, with issues like too-bright images and strange glows on faces, while Midjourney excels in creating realistic humans and scenes.
  • 🔍 Both AIs struggle with pixel art, often resulting in chaotic or mosaic-like images rather than clean pixel art.
  • 🏆 Midjourney consistently portrays aesthetics in its images, earning it a point over Stable Diffusion in this style comparison.
  • 💡 Stable Diffusion and Midjourney both performed well in minimalist style, but Midjourney's cleaner logos and fewer unnecessary details gave it the edge.
  • 🎭 Midjourney has a special model for anime aesthetics, which contributed to its higher quality in this category compared to Stable Diffusion.
  • ✏️ In sketch style, Midjourney's images have a natural look that can be mistaken for human-drawn sketches, giving it a point over Stable Diffusion.
  • 📸 Both AIs handled the vintage photo style well, with Stable Diffusion's images having a photorealistic feel despite a consistent strange glow.
  • 🏁 After comparing images, Midjourney scored higher with 83 points, showing its overall superiority in image generation.
  • 💰 Stable Diffusion can be favored for being free, while Midjourney requires at least a $10 monthly subscription for access.
  • 🔓 As the only open-source and free AI image generator, there's hope that Stable Diffusion will improve and compete with Midjourney in the future.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video script?

    -The main topic of the video script is a comparison between Midjourney V6 and Stable Diffusion 3, two AI image generators, across different image styles to determine which one performs better.

  • What are the image styles compared in the script?

    -The image styles compared in the script include photo realism, pixel art, aesthetic, minimalist logos, and sketches.

  • How does Stable Diffusion 3 perform in photo realism according to the script?

    -According to the script, Stable Diffusion 3's performance in photo realism has not improved much, with issues such as overly bright images, strange glow on faces, and occasional human anatomy errors.

  • What is Midjourney known for in terms of image generation?

    -Midjourney is known for its ability to create photorealistic humans and scenes, as well as having a special model for anime aesthetics.

  • How does the script evaluate the performance of both AI generators in pixel art?

    -The script states that both AI generators did well with pixel art, but Midjourney's images were more consistent in portraying the aesthetics throughout.

  • What is APOP AI, and how does it relate to the video script?

    -APOP AI is an AI platform that transforms photos into lifelike AI-generated portraits and videos. It is mentioned in the script as a tool for digital art and content creation, but it is not directly compared to Midjourney V6 or Stable Diffusion 3.

  • What is the final score after the image comparison in the script?

    -The final score after the image comparison is 83 in favor of Midjourney.

  • Is there any additional point given to Stable Diffusion in the script?

    -Yes, additional points are given to Stable Diffusion for being a free model, offering more tools and flexibility, and for less censorship.

  • What is the script's conclusion about the two AI image generators?

    -The script concludes that Midjourney V6 is much better than Stable Diffusion 3, but it also expresses hope that Stable Diffusion will catch up in the future as it is the only open-source and free AI image generator available.

  • How does the script suggest following updates on AI image generators?

    -The script suggests following updates on AI image generators through their YouTube channel and website.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 AI Image Generators Comparison

This paragraph introduces a comparison between Stable Diffusion 3 and Moury, two AI image generators. The aim is to evaluate their performance across different styles using the same prompt. The comparison includes photo realism, pixel art, and other styles, with points awarded based on the quality and consistency of the generated images. The paragraph also mentions an advertisement for Apop AI, a platform for transforming photos into AI-generated portraits and videos. The comparison concludes with a preliminary point tally, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each model in generating photorealistic and pixel art images.

05:24

🏆 Final Verdict on AI Image Generators

The second paragraph wraps up the comparison by discussing the performance of both AI image generators in additional styles, such as minimalist logos and anim aesthetics. It notes the issues with unwanted details and limbs in Stable Diffusion's images, while Moury's images are praised for their natural look and resemblance to hand-drawn sketches. The paragraph also acknowledges Stable Diffusion as a free model, contrasting it with Moury's subscription-based access. The final score favors Moury, but additional points are considered for Stable Diffusion's open-source nature and lesser censorship. The paragraph ends with a note on the potential for Stable Diffusion to improve and a promise to keep the audience updated on future developments.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Midjourney V6

Midjourney V6 refers to the sixth version of the AI image generator known as Midjourney. It is mentioned as a competitor in the comparison for the best AI image generator. In the video, it is highlighted for its ability to create photorealistic humans and scenes, which is one of the criteria for evaluation in the comparison.

💡Stable Diffusion 3

Stable Diffusion 3 is the third iteration of the AI model that generates images, also part of the comparison in the video. It is noted for being available for free download and local use, setting it apart from Midjourney V6 which requires a subscription. The script discusses its performance in various image styles, including photo realism and pixel art.

💡Photo Realism

Photo realism is a style of image generation where the output appears as if it were taken by a camera, aiming for a high degree of realism. In the video, both AI models are evaluated based on their ability to generate photorealistic images. Midjourney V6 is favored for its consistent performance in this style, while Stable Diffusion 3 has some issues with brightness and human anatomy.

💡Pixel Art

Pixel art is a form of digital art where images are created on the pixel level, often resulting in a blocky, retro style. The video script mentions a comparison of how both AI models handle pixel art, with Midjourney V6 and Stable Diffusion 3 both receiving points for their efforts, although there are some issues with the style's execution in the generated images.

💡Aesthetics

Aesthetics in the context of the video refers to the visual style or the characteristic visual elements of the generated images. The script mentions that Midjourney V6 portrayed aesthetics more consistently, which is a key point in evaluating the quality of the generated images.

💡Apop AI

Apop AI is introduced in the video as an AI platform that transforms photos into AI-generated portraits and videos. It is mentioned as a tool for digital art and content creation, offering a range of styles and settings, and is highlighted for its image-to-video feature, which brings still images to life.

💡Minimalist Logos

Minimalist logos are a design style characterized by simplicity and the use of basic geometric shapes. In the video, the script discusses the performance of both AI models in generating minimalist logos, where Midjourney V6 is noted for having fewer unnecessary details.

💡Anim Aesthetics

Anim aesthetics refer to a visual style often associated with animation, characterized by vibrant colors and exaggerated features. The video mentions that Midjourney V6 has a special model dedicated to this aesthetic, which gives it an advantage in generating images in this style.

💡Sketches

Sketches in the context of the video are hand-drawn images that have a rough, unfinished look. The script notes that Midjourney V6's images have a natural look that can sometimes be confused with actual human-drawn sketches, indicating a high level of realism in its output.

💡Old Photographs

Old photographs is a style that emulates the look of vintage photos, often with a sepia tone or grainy texture. The video script mentions that Stable Diffusion 3's images have a feel of old photographs, despite some issues with a strange glow effect.

💡Censorship

Censorship in the context of the video refers to the limitations or restrictions placed on the content generated by the AI models. The script notes that Midjourney V6 has less censorship, which could be an advantage for users seeking more creative freedom in their image generation.

Highlights

Midjourney V6 and Stable Diffusion 3 are compared across various categories to determine the best AI image generator.

Stable Diffusion 3's medium version is available for download and local use.

Photo realism in Stable Diffusion 3 has not seen significant improvement, with issues like bright images and strange glow on faces.

Midjourney is recognized for creating photorealistic humans and scenes, giving it an edge in this category.

Both AI models struggle with generating pixel art, often resulting in chaotic or mosaic-like images.

In the aesthetic portrayal, Midjourney shows more consistency, earning it a point over Stable Diffusion.

Apop AI is introduced as a platform for transforming photos into AI-generated portraits and videos.

Stable Diffusion performs well in simple styles but has issues with unnecessary details and artifacts.

Midjourney's minimalist logos lack unnecessary details, giving it a point in this comparison.

Midjourney has a special model for anim aesthetics, which contributes to its point in this category.

Stable Diffusion's images appear less hand-drawn compared to Midjourney's more natural sketches.

Both AIs handle the vintage style well, resulting in a tie for this category.

The final score after image comparison favors Midjourney with a score of 83.

Stable Diffusion earns additional points for being a free model, unlike Midjourney's subscription-based access.

Midjourney V6 is currently superior to Stable Diffusion 3, with hopes that the latter will improve in the future.

Stable Diffusion is the only open-source and free AI image generator available.

Updates on the comparison and advancements in AI image generators will be provided on the YouTube channel and website.