Stable Diffusion VS Dall-E (Honest Comparison)
TLDRIn this video, a comparison is made between Stable Diffusion and Dall-E, two AI image generation platforms. Both are easy to access, but Dall-E offers larger images and more free credits, making it more affordable for users. While Dall-E excels in photorealism, Stable Diffusion is better suited for artistic style paintings and generating beautiful faces. Dall-E also provides a commercial license and ownership over prompts, whereas Stable Diffusion only offers a commercial license for the images. In terms of speed, Stable Diffusion is faster in generating images. However, Dall-E's image editor is more intuitive across different browsers. Both platforms have censorship policies, but Dall-E's are less restrictive. The video concludes by advocating for Stable Diffusion to reintroduce the option to disable safe mode to remain competitive, especially with the upcoming release of Google's similar service.
Takeaways
- 🔑 **Ease of Access**: Both Stable Diffusion and Dall-E are user-friendly, allowing users to create accounts and start generating images within a minute.
- 💵 **Affordability**: Stable Diffusion offers 10512x512 images for free, with a $10 charge for 1000 more. Dall-E provides 200 free images (50 credits) and an additional 15 credits per month, with larger image sizes.
- 📏 **Image Size**: Dall-E's images are 1024x1024, four times larger than Stable Diffusion's, which offers a cost-effective disadvantage for the latter when generating larger images.
- 🎨 **Quality**: Dall-E excels at photorealistic images, while Stable Diffusion is better suited for artistic style paintings and generating beautiful faces.
- 🚀 **Speed**: Stable Diffusion is faster in generating images, taking approximately 2-5 seconds, compared to Dall-E's 10-20 seconds.
- 🧩 **Intuitiveness**: Both platforms are intuitive, but Dall-E's image editor is noted for its reliability across different browsers without glitches.
- 📜 **Policy**: Dall-E provides commercial ownership over prompts in addition to the images, whereas Stable Diffusion offers a commercial license only for the images.
- 🚫 **Censorship**: Dall-E has a ban list that prevents searching for certain topics, while Stable Diffusion allows searching but blurs inappropriate images, which users still pay for.
- 🛡️ **Censorship Control**: A previous option to disable censorship on Stable Diffusion has been removed, which is seen as a disadvantage compared to Dall-E's policy.
- 🌟 **Recommendation**: The speaker is rooting for Stable Diffusion but suggests that it needs to offer the ability to disable safe mode to compete effectively with other platforms like Google's upcoming offering.
- ⚖️ **People's Choice**: The underdog, Crayons, is highlighted for its zero-filter policy and commercial license, setting a standard that other platforms, including Stable Diffusion, should consider adopting.
Q & A
Which two AI image generation platforms are being compared in the video?
-The video compares Stable Diffusion and Dall-E.
What are the six factors that users generally care about when comparing software?
-The six factors are ease of access, affordability, quality, speed, intuitiveness, and policy.
How does the affordability of Stable Diffusion compare to Dall-E?
-Stable Diffusion offers 10512 by 512 images for free and then charges $10 for about a thousand more images. Dall-E provides 50 credits for free (which translates to 200 images) and also gives 15 free credits each month. Dall-E's images are 1024x1024, making them four times larger than Stable Diffusion's images.
Which platform is better for generating photorealistic images?
-Dall-E is better at generating photorealistic images, while Stable Diffusion excels at creating artistic style paintings and beautiful faces.
Which platform is faster in generating images?
-Stable Diffusion is faster, taking about 5 seconds to generate images, compared to Dall-E which averages between 10 to 20 seconds.
What is the main difference in the user interface between Dall-E and Stable Diffusion?
-Dall-E's image editor works smoothly in both Google Chrome and Firefox without glitches, whereas Stable Diffusion's interface may have glitches when drawing outside the canvas.
What are the differences in the commercial license and ownership policies between the two platforms?
-Both platforms provide a commercial license for the work created. However, Dall-E also offers commercial ownership over the prompts used to generate images, while Stable Diffusion only provides a commercial license for the images themselves.
How do the censorship policies of Dall-E and Stable Diffusion differ?
-Dall-E does not allow searches for items on the ban list, whereas Stable Diffusion allows searches for any term but will blur out images it deems inappropriate. A notable issue with Stable Diffusion is that users still pay for blurred images.
What feature is suggested for Stable Diffusion to improve its competitiveness?
-The video suggests that Stable Diffusion should bring back the option to disable the safe mode as a feature to improve its competitiveness, especially when compared to other platforms like Google's upcoming offering.
Which platform is mentioned as the 'underdog' that deserves support?
-Crayon is mentioned as the underdog that deserves support, as it is the only free and available image generating website with a commercial license that has zero filters.
What is the main issue raised by the video regarding Stable Diffusion's censorship policy?
-The main issue raised is that Stable Diffusion's censorship policy, which blurs out inappropriate images, is less favorable because users still have to pay for those blurred images. The removal of the option to turn off censorship is seen as a mistake that could affect its recommendation over competitors.
What is the conclusion of the video regarding the comparison between Stable Diffusion and Dall-E?
-The conclusion is that while both platforms have their strengths, Dall-E currently offers more value for money, especially considering the image size and quality. Stable Diffusion is recommended for character designers due to its ability to generate beautiful faces, but for photorealism and overall value, Dall-E has the advantage.
Outlines
🌟 Software Comparison: Stable Diffusion vs. Dolly
This paragraph introduces a comparison between the Stable Diffusion and Dolly websites, focusing on user-centric aspects such as ease of access, affordability, quality, speed, intuitiveness, and policy. Both platforms are easy to access, with quick account creation and image generation. In terms of affordability, Stable Diffusion offers 105 free images and charges $10 for 1000 more, while Dolly provides 200 free images with an additional 15 credits per month. However, Dolly's images are larger (1024x1024), offering better value for money. Quality-wise, Dolly excels in photorealism, whereas Stable Diffusion is better for artistic style paintings and generating faces. Speed is in favor of Stable Diffusion, which generates images faster than Dolly. Intuitiveness is slightly better with Dolly due to its more reliable image editor. Regarding policy, Dolly provides commercial ownership over prompts, while Stable Diffusion offers a license only for the images. Both have censorship, but Dolly's approach is less restrictive.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Stable Diffusion
💡Dall-E
💡Ease of Access
💡Affordability
💡Quality
💡Speed
💡Intuitiveness
💡Policy
💡Censorship
💡Commercial License
💡Image Size
Highlights
Stable Diffusion and Dall-E are both easy to access with account creation leading to immediate image generation.
Stable Diffusion offers 10512x512 images for free, with a $10 charge for 1000 additional images.
Dall-E provides 50 credits for free, equating to 200 free initial images, and 15 free credits each month.
Dall-E's images are 1024x1024, four times larger than Stable Diffusion's, offering more value for money.
Stable Diffusion excels at artistic style paintings and generating beautiful faces.
Dall-E is superior for photorealistic images, while Stable Diffusion is favored for character design.
Stable Diffusion is faster in image generation, taking approximately 2-5 seconds.
Dall-E's image generation takes an average of 10-20 seconds.
Both platforms offer commercial licenses for work, but Dall-E also provides commercial ownership over prompts.
Stable Diffusion has a censorship policy that blurs deemed inappropriate images, even if paid for.
Dall-E does not allow searches for banned content, whereas Stable Diffusion allows searches but enforces censorship.
The removal of the option to disable censorship on Stable Diffusion is seen as a mistake.
Crayon is noted as an underdog with zero filters and a commercial license included.
The reviewer suggests Stable Diffusion should reintroduce the option to disable safe mode to stay competitive.
Google's upcoming release, Party, poses a challenge to both Dall-E and Stable Diffusion.
The reviewer expresses frustration with Stable Diffusion's censorship policy, which may affect its recommendation over Google's Party.
The video concludes with a call for Stable Diffusion to give users the option to disable safe mode to remain the people's choice.