OpenAI-o1 on Cursor | First Impressions and Tests vs Claude 3.5

All About AI
13 Sept 202430:34

TLDRThe video offers first impressions and a comparative analysis of OpenAI's new reasoning model, o1, using the coding platform Cursor. The host is excited about o1's ability to think before responding and its potential for complex reasoning. The video tests o1 against Claude 3.5 and GPT-4 in building a space game and a Bitcoin trading simulation system. While o1 shows promise in debugging and strategy generation, it falls short in speed and cost-effectiveness compared to Claude 3.5. The host concludes that more exploration is needed to fully harness o1's capabilities.

Takeaways

  • 😀 OpenAI has released a new reasoning model called 'o1', designed for more complex tasks and problem-solving.
  • 🔍 The o1 model is part of a series of large language models trained with reinforcement learning for complex reasoning.
  • 💭 o1 models 'think' before answering, using internal reasoning tokens to break down prompts and generate responses.
  • 🚀 The o1 model is compared with Claude 3.5 and GPT-4 for debugging and building tests using the Cursor platform.
  • 💼 There are limitations to the o1 model, such as fixed temperatures and no streaming or system messages.
  • 💰 The o1 model comes in two versions: 'o1 mini' for coding and math tasks, and 'o1 preview' for broader general knowledge applications.
  • 💵 The pricing for o1 models is higher compared to previous models, with 'o1 preview' costing $15 per million tokens and 'o1 mini' being five times cheaper.
  • 🛠️ The video demonstrates setting up the o1 model with Cursor, including adding the model and running initial tests.
  • 🎮 A space game development test was conducted to compare the o1 model with Claude 3.5, with the latter performing better in terms of speed and functionality.
  • 💡 The video concludes with the presenter expressing excitement about the potential of the o1 model but noting the need for further exploration to understand its optimal use cases.

Q & A

  • What is the main focus of the video?

    -The main focus of the video is to provide first impressions and tests of OpenAI's new reasoning model, called 'o1', using the coding platform Cursor. The video compares the performance of the o1 model with that of Claude 3.5 and GPT-4.

  • What are the key features of the o1 model mentioned in the video?

    -The o1 model is designed to spend more time thinking before responding, reason through complex tasks, and solve harder problems than previous models in areas such as science, coding, and general knowledge.

  • How does the o1 model incorporate reasoning tokens?

    -The o1 model uses reasoning tokens to think, break down its understanding of the prompt, consider multiple approaches, and generate responses. After generating reasoning tokens, the model produces an answer with completion tokens and discards the reasoning tokens from the context.

  • What are the limitations of the o1 model discussed in the video?

    -Some limitations of the o1 model mentioned in the video include the inability to stream, fixed temperatures, and restricted access to system messages. Additionally, the API usage is limited to tier five developers with a rate limit of 20 requests per minute.

  • What is the difference between o1 mini and o1 preview?

    -The o1 mini is a faster and cheaper version of the o1 model, particularly adept at coding, math, and science tasks where extensive general knowledge isn't required. The o1 preview is designed to reason about hard problems using broad general knowledge.

  • What is the pricing for the o1 models?

    -The o1 preview is priced at $15 per million tokens, while the o1 mini is five times cheaper at $3 per million tokens.

  • How does the video compare the o1 model with Claude 3.5 in terms of coding a simple game?

    -The video compares the o1 model with Claude 3.5 by attempting to code a simple space game using both models. The o1 model took significantly longer to respond and had issues with game functionality, while Claude 3.5 provided a faster and more functional game code.

  • What is the intended use case for the o1 model according to the video?

    -The video suggests that the o1 model is intended for complex reasoning tasks that require a broad general knowledge base, rather than simple coding tasks that can be handled more efficiently by other models like Claude 3.5.

  • What was the outcome of testing the o1 model on a more complex task involving API and simulation?

    -In the video, the o1 model was tested on a complex task involving setting up an API endpoint and running a Bitcoin price simulation. The model provided a slower response and had issues with strategy execution compared to Claude 3.5, which performed the task more effectively.

  • What is the conclusion of the video regarding the o1 model's performance?

    -The conclusion of the video is that the o1 model showed promise in complex reasoning tasks but was slower and less effective in simpler coding tasks compared to Claude 3.5. The video suggests that further exploration and understanding are needed to determine the best use cases for the o1 model.

Outlines

00:00

🤖 Introduction to OpenAI's New AI Model

The speaker expresses excitement over OpenAI's release of their new reasoning model, called '01'. They plan to conduct a first impression test using the model for debugging and compare its performance with other models like GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. Before diving into testing, the speaker reviews the new model's features, highlighting its ability to think before responding and solve complex tasks in science, coding, and more. The model uses 'reasoning tokens' to break down prompts and generate responses. The speaker also mentions the limitations of the model, such as fixed temperatures and the inability to stream or use system messages. They briefly touch on the different versions available, like '01 mini' for coding and math tasks and '01 preview' for general knowledge problems. Pricing information is provided, with '01 preview' being more expensive than '01 mini'. The speaker then sets up a Python script to interact with the model via API, showcasing the initial steps in coding and the response time of the model.

05:01

🚀 Testing the New AI Model with Practical Tasks

The speaker moves on to practical testing of the '01' model by setting up a development environment with Cursor, an AI development tool. They demonstrate how to select the '01' models within Cursor and use them to create a simple game. The game development serves as a testbed to compare the '01' models with the existing GPT-3.5 model. The speaker creates a space game using Next.js and assets like sprites and sounds. They provide a prompt for the AI to follow, which includes instructions for creating the game. The speaker then runs the prompt through GPT-3.5 and observes the output, noting the compilation errors and the need for fixes. Despite the issues, the speaker is excited about the potential of integrating the new AI models into their workflow.

10:02

🎮 Evaluating Game Development with AI Models

The speaker evaluates the performance of the '01 mini' model by using it to develop the same space game. They encounter issues with the model's response, noting the lack of instructions and the slow speed of execution. Despite these challenges, the speaker appreciates the detailed explanation provided by the model. They attempt to run the game but face further problems with the score not updating and the absence of sound. The speaker tries to debug the issues but concludes that the '01 mini' model failed to produce a working game, unlike the GPT-3.5 model. They express disappointment but remain open to further exploration of the '01' model's capabilities.

15:04

🛠️ Debugging and Developing Complex Systems with AI

The speaker attempts to use the '01 preview' model to develop a more complex system involving an API endpoint and a Bitcoin price tracking simulation. They set up the project structure and begin implementing the code. However, they encounter numerous errors and slow response times, leading to a lack of confidence in the model's ability to handle the task. Despite the model's detailed explanations and suggestions for code changes, the speaker is unable to get the system running successfully. They compare this experience unfavorably to the more straightforward and efficient process they had with the GPT-3.5 model.

20:04

📈 Backtesting Bitcoin Trading Strategies with AI

The speaker outlines a plan to build a system that uses an API to fetch Bitcoin prices and backtest different trading algorithms. They start by using the GPT-3.5 model to create the system, which includes setting up Docker and using a composer. The speaker is impressed with the ease of setup and the successful execution of the strategies, which yield positive results. They then attempt the same task using the '01 preview' model, noting the significant increase in response time. Despite following the model's instructions, the speaker faces issues with the strategies not performing as expected and the system crashing. They conclude that the GPT-3.5 model provided a better solution for this task.

25:06

🔍 Reflecting on the First Impressions of the New AI Model

In the final paragraph, the speaker reflects on their first impressions of the '01' model. They express excitement about the potential of the model but also note the challenges they faced during testing. The speaker acknowledges the need for further exploration and understanding of the model's capabilities. They invite viewers to share their experiences and use cases for the new model and express their intention to continue experimenting with it. The speaker concludes by stating their preference for the GPT-3.5 model for now but remains open to incorporating the new model into their workflow as they gain more experience with it.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡OpenAI-o1

OpenAI-o1 refers to a new series of AI models developed by OpenAI, designed to perform complex reasoning tasks. These models are capable of 'thinking' before they respond, allowing them to reason through complex tasks and solve harder problems than previous models. In the context of the video, the host is excited about testing this new model using the Cursor platform to see how it compares to other models like Claude 3.5 and GPT-40.

💡Cursor

Cursor is a code-writing platform that allows users to interact with AI models to generate, debug, and test code. In the video, the host uses Cursor to conduct first impression tests and comparisons between different AI models, including the newly released OpenAI-o1 model. The platform is used to build and test applications, such as a space game and a Bitcoin price tracking system.

💡Reasoning model

A reasoning model in AI refers to a system capable of logical reasoning, which involves using reasoning tokens to break down understanding of a prompt, considering multiple approaches, and generating responses. The video discusses the OpenAI-o1 model's ability to reason through tasks, which sets it apart from other models and is a key focus of the tests conducted by the host.

💡Chain of Thought

The 'Chain of Thought' is a process mentioned in the video where AI models use reasoning tokens to think through a problem, breaking it down into smaller parts before generating a response. This is a feature of the OpenAI-o1 model, which is said to produce a long internal chain of thought before responding to a user's query.

💡Reinforcement learning

Reinforcement learning is a type of machine learning where an agent learns to make decisions by taking actions in an environment to maximize some notion of cumulative reward. The video script mentions that OpenAI-o1 series models are trained with reinforcement learning to perform complex reasoning.

💡API

API stands for Application Programming Interface, which is a set of rules and protocols for building and interacting with software applications. In the video, the host discusses the process of setting up and using the OpenAI API, specifically mentioning the requirements for API usage tier five to access the new models.

💡Claude 3.5

Claude 3.5 is an AI model mentioned in the video as a point of comparison for the new OpenAI-o1 model. The host compares the performance of Claude 3.5 with the new model in terms of speed, accuracy, and ability to generate code for specific tasks, such as creating a space game.

💡Docker

Docker is an open platform for developing, shipping, and running applications. It allows users to package an application with all of its dependencies into a 'container' that can run on any system. In the video, Docker is used to set up a system for fetching Bitcoin prices and running backtesting simulations.

💡CoinGecko API

The CoinGecko API is a service that provides cryptocurrency data such as price, market data, developer activity, community activity, and more. In the video, the host discusses using the CoinGecko API to extract Bitcoin prices for a backtesting simulation system.

💡Backtesting

Backtesting in finance refers to the process of testing a new investment strategy or system against past data to see how it would have performed. In the video, the host is building a system to backtest different Bitcoin trading strategies using historical price data.

Highlights

OpenAI has released a new reasoning model called 'o1'.

The o1 model is designed to spend more time thinking before responding.

o1 models can reason through complex tasks and solve harder problems in science, coding, and more.

OpenAI introduced reasoning tokens for the o1 models to break down understanding and generate responses.

The o1 model produces an answer with visible completion tokens after generating reasoning tokens.

There are limitations with the o1 model, such as no streaming and fixed temperatures.

o1 mini is a faster and cheaper version of o1, suitable for tasks that don't require extensive general knowledge.

o1 preview is designed for reasoning about hard problems using broad general knowledge.

Pricing for o1 preview is $15 per million tokens, and for o1 mini, it's one-third of that.

ChatGPT Plus and teams will have access to the o1 models starting today.

Developers with API usage tier five can start prototyping with the o1 API today.

The rate limit for the o1 API is 20 requests per minute.

The video demonstrates setting up the o1 model with Cursor and creating a Python script to interact with the API.

A test is conducted to write a bash script that makes a matrix and prints the transpose using the o1 model.

The video compares the o1 model's performance in creating a space game with the CLA 3.5 model.

The o1 mini model struggled with the space game implementation, lacking sound and having a high score that increased on its own.

The o1 preview model took significantly longer to respond and had issues with loading assets and firing bullets in the space game.

The video concludes that for the space game creation task, CLA 3.5 outperformed the o1 models.

The video moves on to test the o1 models on a more complex task involving API endpoints and backtesting Bitcoin trading strategies.

CLA 3.5 provided a quicker and more successful setup for the Bitcoin trading simulation compared to the o1 preview model.

The o1 preview model had difficulties executing the Bitcoin trading strategies, with only the Buy and Hold strategy showing a profit.

The video ends with the conclusion that more time and experimentation are needed to fully understand the capabilities of the o1 models.