MUSICIANS ARE SCR*WED - I tested the ChatGPT for Music, Suno AI Music Generator

Konvos with Kubota
28 Mar 202415:25

TLDRThe video script discusses the impact of AI on music artists, as the creator explores the capabilities of an AI music platform called 'sunno AI'. They experiment with various prompts and musical styles, noting the platform's versatility and impressive output. However, concerns are raised about the potential for AI to replace human musicians, affecting independent artists the most. The video emphasizes the need for fair use of AI and the importance of supporting real artists, while also recognizing AI's potential as a creative tool for inspiration.

Takeaways

  • 🎵 The music artist expresses concern over AI potentially replacing human musicians due to its impressive capabilities.
  • 🤖 The artist explores AI's music generation features, noting its ability to create songs based on specific prompts and styles.
  • 🌐 The script mentions the versatility of AI, as it can generate music in different languages and genres, such as Russian heavy metal and K-Pop.
  • 🎶 AI-generated music has a digital aspect to the vocals, which can be identified by a quantized or pitch-corrected sound.
  • 💡 The artist acknowledges the potential of AI in the music industry, but also highlights the challenges it poses for independent musicians.
  • 📉 The script discusses the economic impact of AI on musicians, particularly the distribution of money from streaming services and the potential loss of freelance jobs.
  • 🤝 There is mention of the American Federation of Musicians addressing AI with entertainment studios, but concerns remain for independent artists not covered by these regulations.
  • 🚫 The artist argues that AI-generated music may take away revenue and opportunities from real artists, as it can mimic but not replicate human experiences.
  • 💭 The artist suggests that AI music generators could be a tool for inspiration, but emphasizes the value of original human creativity.
  • 🌟 Despite the challenges, the artist remains hopeful that AI will not replace music entirely, as human experiences shape unique sounds.
  • 📢 The script ends with a call for support for real music artists and encourages discussion on the future of AI in the creative industry.

Q & A

  • What is the main concern of the music artist speaking in the transcript?

    -The music artist is concerned about the potential replacement of human musicians by AI, as they find the capabilities of AI in music creation impressive and potentially threatening to independent artists.

  • What feature of the AI platform does the artist explore first?

    -The artist first explores the 'create' tab of the AI platform, where they can type in a prompt and generate music based on that prompt.

  • What was the first song request the artist made to the AI?

    -The artist's first song request to the AI was to write an Indie pop dreamy sad song about losing a parrot.

  • How does the artist describe the AI's ability to handle different languages and genres?

    -The artist describes the AI as very versatile, capable of handling different languages like Russian and creating songs in various genres such as K-Pop, heavy metal, and anime rap.

  • What specific issue does the artist raise about AI music generators and independent musicians?

    -The artist raises the issue that AI music generators could potentially take away jobs from independent musicians, especially in areas like streaming and freelance work, as they can generate music more cheaply and efficiently.

  • What example does the artist provide to illustrate the potential impact of AI on music industry earnings?

    -The artist explains that money from streaming services is distributed based on the number of streams an artist brings in. If AI-generated music gains a lot of streams, it could take away earnings from real artists who rely on those streams for income.

  • What action has the artist taken after understanding the implications of AI tools?

    -After understanding the implications, the artist has decided not to use AI tools for their music and instead focus on creating original content.

  • What positive aspect of AI music generators does the artist mention?

    -The artist mentions that AI music generators can be a great tool for finding inspiration in instrumentation or lyrics and can be used to create personalized songs for special occasions.

  • What is the artist's final stance on the future of music and AI?

    -The artist believes that while AI can imitate sounds, it cannot generate its own unique experiences to create something truly original. They think that human musicians still have a place in the future of music due to their unique experiences and creativity.

  • What does the artist suggest as a potential solution for the challenges faced by independent artists due to AI?

    -The artist suggests that there needs to be more discussion and regulation around the use of AI in the music industry to protect independent artists, as current regulations may not cover all musicians, especially those working independently.

Outlines

00:00

🎵 AI and the Future of Music Creation

The paragraph discusses the potential impact of AI on music artists, as the speaker explores the capabilities of an AI music platform called 'sunno AI'. The speaker is initially skeptical and concerned about AI replacing human artists, but after experimenting with the platform, they are impressed by its ability to generate music based on prompts. The AI creates full instrumentation and lyrics for songs in various genres, showing its versatility. Despite the impressive technology, the speaker notes that there's a digital aspect to the AI-generated music that gives it away as not human-made. They also touch on the broader implications for the music industry, including the potential for AI to take away jobs from independent artists and the need for regulations to protect creators.

05:02

🤔 The Impact of AI on Creative Industries

This paragraph delves into the wider concerns about AI's impact on various creative industries, including music. The speaker acknowledges the novelty of AI and its uncertain future implications for creatives. They discuss the pushback from creative communities against AI's use of existing art to generate new content, citing examples such as the WGA strikes and lawsuits against AI companies. The speaker specifically addresses the music industry, noting that while some ground rules have been established, many independent artists remain unprotected. They express concern that AI-generated music could take away income and job opportunities from real artists, and they share their personal decision to not use AI tools for their music after understanding the potential consequences.

10:04

💭 Balancing AI's Benefits and Drawbacks

The speaker reflects on the dual nature of AI's impact on music artists. While they recognize the potential threats to independent artists' livelihoods, they also see positive uses for AI in music creation. They suggest that AI can serve as a tool for artists seeking inspiration or experimenting with different instrumentation and lyrics. The speaker emphasizes that despite AI's advancements, human experiences and emotions are unique and cannot be replicated by AI, ensuring that human artists will always have a place in creating original music. They invite the audience to share their thoughts on the future of AI in the creative field and encourage support for real artists.

15:04

📢 A Message of Support and Connection

In the final paragraph, the speaker shifts gears to address a personal connection, reaching out to an individual they had previously spoken with. They acknowledge life's challenges and the choices we make when faced with adversity. The speaker expresses their concern and offers support, showing a human side beyond the discussion on AI and music. This paragraph serves as a reminder of the importance of human connection and support in times of struggle, contrasting with the impersonal nature of AI discussed earlier in the script.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI music generation

AI music generation refers to the process where artificial intelligence algorithms create music based on given prompts or inputs. In the video, the artist explores AI's capability to generate music, expressing concern about its potential impact on musicians' jobs and creativity. The artist uses an AI platform called 'sunno AI' to generate songs with specific themes and styles, highlighting the technology's versatility and potential to replace human musicians in certain applications.

💡Creatives

Creatives are individuals who work in various creative industries such as music, art, writing, and design. In the context of the video, the artist discusses the potential threat AI poses to creatives' jobs and the unique value they bring to their work. The artist emphasizes the importance of supporting real artists and acknowledges the challenges faced by independent creators in the age of AI-generated content.

💡Music industry

The music industry encompasses the businesses and organizations involved in the creation, production, and sale of music. The video addresses the music industry's response to AI, including the American Federation of Musicians' discussions with entertainment studios and the distribution of royalties from streaming platforms. The artist expresses concern about the impact of AI-generated music on the income and opportunities of real artists within this industry.

💡Streaming platforms

Streaming platforms are online services that allow users to listen to music or watch videos on demand. In the video, the artist discusses how platforms like Spotify distribute income to artists based on streams and how AI-generated music could potentially affect this revenue model. The concern is that money earned from AI-generated content might reduce the income available to human artists.

💡Independent artists

Independent artists are musicians or creators who produce and distribute their work without being signed to a major record label or corporate entity. The video highlights the challenges faced by independent artists in the face of AI-generated music, as they often lack the protection and support systems available to more established artists. The artist identifies with this group and worries about their future prospects.

💡AI ethics

AI ethics involve the moral and legal considerations surrounding the development and use of artificial intelligence. The video touches on the ethical concerns of AI in the creative field, such as AI potentially 'stealing' from real artists by using their work to generate new content without permission or proper attribution. The artist also mentions the legal disputes arising from these issues.

💡Artistic expression

Artistic expression is the process by which artists communicate their unique perspectives and emotions through various creative mediums like music, visual art, or writing. The video emphasizes the irreplaceable nature of human artistic expression, suggesting that AI, despite its capabilities, cannot replicate the personal experiences and emotions that shape an artist's work.

💡Job displacement

Job displacement occurs when technological advancements, such as AI, replace human labor, leading to unemployment or a shift in job types. The artist expresses concern that AI-generated music could lead to job displacement for musicians and other creative professionals, as companies may opt for cost-effective AI solutions over hiring human artists.

💡Digital vocals

Digital vocals refer to artificially generated or manipulated voices used in music. In the context of the video, the artist notes that AI-generated music often has a distinct 'digital' sound to the vocals, which can be identified as not being produced by a human singer. This aspect of AI music generation is seen as both a limitation and a giveaway to the technology's involvement.

💡Artistic inspiration

Artistic inspiration is the spark or influence that motivates artists to create new works. The video suggests that AI-generated music can serve as a tool for artists seeking inspiration in instrumentation or lyrics, offering a new way to explore creative ideas without replacing the human touch.

💡Streaming royalties

Streaming royalties are the payments made to artists, record labels, and other rights holders for the use of their music on streaming platforms. The video discusses the complex system of royalties and how AI-generated music could disrupt the traditional distribution of these earnings, potentially taking away income from human artists.

Highlights

The music artist expresses concern over the potential of AI replacing human artists in the music industry.

The artist explores the capabilities of an AI music platform called 'sunno AI'.

AI can generate music based on a user's prompt, including full instrumentation and lyrics.

The platform's versatility is demonstrated by creating songs in different genres and languages.

The artist notes the digital aspect of AI-generated vocals, which can be easily identified as not human.

AI-generated music could impact independent artists more significantly due to lack of industry protections.

The artist discusses the broader implications of AI on various creative industries, including legal disputes over AI-generated art.

The American Federation of Musicians has established some ground rules for AI in music, but independent artists may still be at risk.

The artist hypothesizes that AI-generated music could earn revenue from streaming platforms at the expense of human artists.

AI music generators could also take away freelance and gig opportunities from music artists.

The artist acknowledges using AI-generated art in the past but expresses a commitment to avoiding such tools in the future.

Despite concerns, the artist sees potential positive uses for AI music generators, such as for personal gifts or inspiration.

The artist believes that human experiences shape unique music sounds that AI cannot replicate.

The artist calls for more discourse on the impact of AI on music and creative industries.

The artist concludes with a hopeful outlook on the future of music and AI, emphasizing the irreplaceable nature of human creativity.