AIR FRYER Silicone Liner vs Air Fryer Parchment Paper - Which is Better in the Air Fryer?

Empowered Cooks
2 Apr 202211:59

TLDRIn this video, Kathy compares silicone liners and parchment paper for air fryer use through various cooking tests. She evaluates aspects such as heat distribution, ease of cleaning, and food release. The silicone liners prove to be reusable, easy to clean, and do not significantly hinder heat transfer. Parchment paper offers convenience and similar cooking results. Kathy also shares a tip for making homemade air fryer parchment paper from regular parchment sheets.

Takeaways

  • 🍳 The video compares silicone liners and parchment paper in an air fryer, using identical models for the test.
  • 📊 The presenter, Kathy, conducts a series of tests including cooking eggs in a basket, cinnamon rolls, and meatballs with vegetables to evaluate both types of liners.
  • 🥚 For the egg in a basket test, silicone liners resulted in slightly drier eggs and some leakage, but they were easy to clean.
  • 🍞 In the cinnamon roll test, silicone liners did not require additional oil and performed comparably to parchment paper in cooking and cleanup.
  • 🍖 The meatball and vegetable test showed that silicone liners did not restrict heat transfer significantly and were easy to clean.
  • 🧽 Silicone liners are reusable and can be cleaned roughly, unlike the non-stick air fryer basket which requires gentler treatment.
  • 🌱 The presenter suggests that silicone liners are more eco-friendly due to their reusability, compared to disposable parchment paper.
  • 💰 The cost of silicone liners is comparable to a large pack of parchment paper, and they can last over a year with regular use.
  • 🔎 The video addresses common questions about silicone liners, such as their heat resistance, cleaning ease, and the need for oil when cooking.
  • 🏠 Kathy also provides a tip on how to make homemade parchment paper for the air fryer using regular parchment paper and a template.

Q & A

  • What are the two types of liners compared in the video?

    -The video compares the use of silicone liners and parchment paper liners in an air fryer.

  • What is the main purpose of using liners in an air fryer according to the video?

    -The main purpose of using liners in an air fryer is to prevent food from sticking and to make cleanup easier.

  • What is the 'five-day use your air fryer challenge' mentioned in the video?

    -The 'five-day use your air fryer challenge' is a program created by Kathy to help air fryer owners maximize their use of the appliance.

  • What is the first recipe tested in the video to compare the effectiveness of the liners?

    -The first recipe tested is 'eggs in a basket', a classic recipe where eggs are cooked in a basket shape using a cookie cutter.

  • How does the silicone liner's heat resistance compare to the parchment paper according to the video?

    -The video suggests that silicone has low thermal conductivity, which means it transfers heat at a slower rate compared to parchment paper.

  • What is the difference in the cleanup process between silicone liners and parchment paper?

    -Parchment paper can be thrown away after use, while silicone liners require scrubbing and can be cleaned more aggressively due to their material.

  • Does the silicone liner need oil to prevent food from sticking, as per the video?

    -The video tests whether oil is necessary on silicone mats and finds that it may not always be needed, depending on the food being cooked.

  • What is the recommended internal temperature for bread when cooking in an air fryer according to the video?

    -The recommended internal temperature for bread when cooking in an air fryer is between 180 to 190 Fahrenheit.

  • How does the video suggest making homemade air fryer parchment paper?

    -The video suggests tracing the air fryer basket onto parchment paper, cutting around the outline, and then folding and cutting the paper to create a custom-sized liner.

  • What is the final verdict on which liner is better, silicone or parchment paper, based on the video?

    -The video concludes that both silicone liners and parchment paper perform similarly in terms of cooking effectiveness, with the choice coming down to whether one prefers the convenience of disposable paper or the eco-friendliness and durability of silicone liners.

Outlines

00:00

🍳 Air Fryer Liner Test: Parchment Paper vs Silicone Mat

In this segment, the host, Kathy, introduces a comparison test between air fryer parchment paper and a reusable silicone mat. She sets up two identical air fryers, placing parchment paper in one and a silicone mat in the other. The goal is to determine which liner is superior. Kathy also mentions her 'Five-Day Use Your Air Fryer Challenge' and invites viewers to register. She addresses common questions about the silicone liners, such as their cleaning ease, heat resistance, and the need for oil. The first test involves cooking 'eggs in a basket,' a classic recipe, using avocado oil for cooking. The results show that both liners perform similarly, with the silicone mat possibly causing the eggs to dry out slightly more. The silicone mat is also shown to be more difficult to separate the eggs from, but it does not fly up like paper might. Kathy concludes that the silicone mat did not cause any significant issues during the test.

05:02

🧽 Cleaning and Reusability of Silicone Mats

Kathy discusses the cleanup process for the silicone mat and parchment paper after the egg test. She finds that the parchment paper can be easily discarded, while the silicone mat requires some scrubbing. Despite this, the silicone mat can withstand rough scrubbing, unlike the non-stick air fryer basket. Kathy then moves on to test the silicone mat with cinnamon rolls, aiming to see if oil is necessary when using silicone mats. She notes that the silicone mat did not require oil for the bagels in a previous test, which stuck to the mat. The cinnamon rolls cook well on the silicone mat, and Kathy is impressed with the results, noting that the base of the rolls is well-cooked. She also discusses the recommended internal temperatures for baked goods and how the silicone mat and parchment paper both achieve these temperatures effectively. Kathy concludes that the silicone mat performs well and is easy to clean, with minimal residue left behind.

10:03

🍖 Meatballs and Vegetables Test with Air Fryer Liners

In the final test, Kathy cooks meatballs and vegetables in both the air fryer with parchment paper and the one with a silicone mat. She lightly mists the food with avocado oil and sets the air fryers to cook at 350 degrees for 10 minutes. She also sets a reminder to shake the air fryers during cooking. After cooking, she checks the internal temperature of the meatballs and finds that those cooked on the silicone mat are slightly cooler than those on the parchment paper. The vegetables cook well in both air fryers. Kathy then examines the cleaning process for both the silicone mat and the parchment paper. She finds that the silicone mat has some grease residue but is generally easy to clean, while the parchment paper is more greasy and has less residue. She concludes that the silicone mat does not significantly restrict heat and performs comparably to the parchment paper. Kathy also demonstrates how to make homemade air fryer parchment paper using a simple tracing and cutting method. She invites viewers to join her air fryer challenge and explore more air fryer tips and recipes in her playlist.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Air Fryer

An air fryer is a kitchen appliance that uses hot air circulation and convection to cook food, typically with less oil than traditional deep frying methods. In the video, the air fryer is the central tool used to compare the effectiveness of silicone liners versus parchment paper. The script mentions using identical air fryers for testing different cooking methods, highlighting the air fryer's role in modern healthy cooking.

💡Silicone Liner

A silicone liner is a reusable, non-stick mat designed for use in an air fryer. It is made from silicone, a material known for its heat resistance and flexibility. The video explores the silicone liner's performance in cooking, its ease of cleaning, and whether it blocks heat, as it is pitted against parchment paper in various cooking tests.

💡Parchment Paper

Parchment paper is a type of paper designed to withstand high temperatures without burning, often used in baking and air frying to prevent food from sticking to the cooking surface. The script discusses the use of parchment paper in an air fryer, comparing its performance to silicone liners in terms of cooking results and ease of cleanup.

💡Thermal Conductivity

Thermal conductivity refers to a material's ability to conduct heat. The script mentions that silicone has low thermal conductivity, which is a property that might seem counterintuitive for use in an air fryer that relies on high heat for cooking. The video investigates whether this property affects the cooking efficiency of the air fryer.

💡Eggs in a Basket

Eggs in a basket is a cooking method where eggs are cooked in a circular cutout of bread, creating a 'basket' around the egg. The video uses this dish as one of the test recipes to compare the cooking results between silicone liners and parchment paper, noting the evenness of cooking and the ease of removal from the air fryer.

💡Cinnamon Rolls

Cinnamon rolls are a type of sweet, yeasted bread roll flavored with cinnamon and sugar, often served with icing. In the video, cinnamon rolls are used as a test recipe to see if oil is necessary when using silicone liners, as they contain their own fat content, which might affect the need for additional oiling.

💡Internal Temperature

Internal temperature is the temperature within the center of a food item, which is crucial for ensuring that food is cooked properly and safely. The video references the recommended internal temperatures for baked goods and uses a thermometer to check the temperature of cooked items, such as meatballs, to ensure they are cooked to the proper level.

💡Meatballs and Vegetables

Meatballs and vegetables are a common air fryer recipe, combining protein and vegetables for a balanced meal. The script uses this recipe to test the heat distribution and cooking effectiveness of silicone liners versus parchment paper, noting the browning and internal temperature of the meatballs as indicators of cooking quality.

💡Dishwasher Safe

The term 'dishwasher safe' refers to the ability of kitchen utensils or tools to be cleaned in a dishwasher without damage. The video discusses the ease of cleaning silicone liners and whether they can be cleaned in a dishwasher, which is a convenience factor for many users.

💡Eco-friendly

Eco-friendly practices involve making choices that minimize harm to the environment. The script contrasts the single-use nature of parchment paper with the reusable silicone liners, suggesting that using silicone liners might be a more eco-friendly option due to their longevity and reduced waste.

Highlights

Comparing air fryer silicone liners to parchment paper for cooking effectiveness.

Using identical air fryers to ensure a fair comparison.

Silicone liners are reusable, whereas parchment paper is disposable.

Testing the heat resistance of silicone liners in an air fryer.

Silicone's low thermal conductivity might affect cooking speed.

Cooking 'eggs in a basket' to evaluate the performance of both liners.

Silicone liners may prevent food from sticking more effectively.

Parchment paper can be easily removed for food handling.

Silicone liners require scrubbing for cleaning, but are dishwasher safe.

Parchment paper leaves minimal residue and is easy to dispose of.

Testing if silicone liners need oil for non-stick properties.

Cinnamon rolls cooked with and without oil on silicone liners.

Silicone liners show no significant difference in cooking performance compared to parchment paper.

Meatballs and vegetables cooked to test heat distribution on silicone liners.

Silicone liners do not restrict heat, similar to parchment paper.

Eco-friendliness and convenience are the main differences between silicone liners and parchment paper.

How to make homemade air fryer parchment paper using regular parchment paper.

Final thoughts on the practicality and cost-effectiveness of silicone liners versus parchment paper.