IS AI ART THE DEATH OF REAL ARTISTS?
TLDRThe video discusses the impact of AI-generated art on the art community, with companies and studios using AI to create art, leading to job losses and concerns over artist rights. It highlights the controversy around AI art, including Disney and other studios' use of it, and the challenges artists face in protecting their work from being used for AI training. The video introduces tools like Glaze and Nightshade, which help artists protect their art from AI mimicry and data theft, and touches on the recent policy changes by Meta and Adobe that further threaten artists' rights.
Takeaways
- 🎨 AI art has sparked controversy in the art community due to its potential impact on real artists.
- 🤖 AI art is created by training on large datasets of real artists' work, including a 6-year-old child's art.
- 🎓 Prestigious institutions like CalArts have posted AI art, raising questions about the value of traditional art education.
- 📈 Companies and studios are increasingly using AI art, which may be linked to layoffs and project cancellations in the animation industry.
- 🚫 Some artists are removing their work from platforms like Instagram to protest AI's use of their art for training purposes.
- 📝 Meta's new policy allows them to use all posted content to train their AI models, leading to concerns about artist rights.
- 🚫 Artists are migrating to new platforms like Cara, which do not use their art for AI training and do not allow AI art.
- 📜 Adobe's updated terms of service have raised concerns about the use of artists' work for AI training without explicit consent.
- 🛡 Tools like Glaze and Nightshade are being developed to protect artists' work from AI mimicry and data poisoning.
- 🔄 Glaze alters artwork in imperceptible ways to AI, while Nightshade distorts features in AI datasets to affect output.
- 🌐 There is ongoing debate about the effectiveness of these tools and whether AI can adapt to bypass them.
Q & A
What is the main concern raised in the video about AI art?
-The main concern is that AI art, trained on datasets of real artists' work, might lead to the death of real artists by undermining their creative efforts and potentially replacing them in the industry.
How does AI art work according to the video?
-AI art is created by training AI on specific datasets, which can include millions of artworks from real artists. Users can even input the names of real artists to mimic their style.
Why did the prestigious animation film festival accept a film that uses AI art?
-The video does not provide a specific reason, but it implies that the acceptance of such a film reflects the growing presence and acceptance of AI art in the industry.
What is the issue with Meta's recent policy change regarding AI?
-Meta's new policy allows them to use all content posted on their platforms to feed their AI models without explicit consent, which raises concerns about the use of artists' work for AI training.
What is the alternative platform that artists are moving to, as mentioned in the video?
-Artists are moving to a new app called Cara, which does not use their art for AI training and does not allow AI art on their platform.
What does Adobe's updated terms of service mean for artists using their software?
-According to the new terms, by using Adobe's software, artists give them permission to use their content for various purposes, including potentially training their AI models.
What is the purpose of the tools Glaze and Nightshade?
-Glaze and Nightshade are tools designed to protect artists' work from being mimicked by AI. Glaze modifies the artwork in a way that is imperceptible to humans but different to AI models, while Nightshade aims to distort the AI model's output by introducing 'poisoned' samples.
How can artists protect their artwork on Instagram from being used for AI training?
-Artists can use watermarks, upload their work at a low DPI, or take a picture within a picture within a picture of their art to make it harder for AI to use their work.
What is the role of Squarespace in the context of AI and artists' work?
-Squarespace allows users to opt out of AI crawlers, meaning that their websites will not be scanned to train AI models, which is beneficial for artists who use their websites as portfolios.
What is the potential impact of using Glaze and Nightshade on the AI art industry?
-The use of Glaze and Nightshade could disrupt the AI art industry by making it more difficult for AI models to mimic artists' styles and by poisoning the datasets that AI relies on, leading to less accurate AI-generated art.
Outlines
🎨 AI Art Controversy and Impact on Artists
The script discusses the ongoing debate in the art community regarding AI-generated art. It highlights instances of AI art being used in advertisements and official posters, such as for the movie 'Civil War Goblins', and the backlash faced by prestigious entities like the animation school and film festivals. The video explains how AI art is created using datasets from thousands of artists, including a 6-year-old child, and the ethical concerns this raises. It also touches on the impact of AI on the job market in animation and the art industry, with studios using AI art leading to layoffs and project cancellations. The script introduces the audience to tools like 'glaze' and 'Nightshade' that artists can use to protect their work from AI replication and manipulation.
🛡️ Protecting Artistic Integrity with Glaze and Nightshade
This paragraph delves into the specifics of how artists can safeguard their work against AI art theft through the use of 'glaze' and 'Nightshade'. 'Glaze' is a tool that modifies artwork in imperceptible ways to humans but significantly to AI models, making it difficult for AI to mimic the style. 'Nightshade', on the other hand, aims to corrupt AI datasets by introducing distorted features. The script provides a walkthrough of using these tools and discusses their effectiveness and the ongoing efforts to update them against new AI models. It also mentions the community's mixed feelings about the necessity of such measures and the potential for AI to be used positively in the future.
🌐 The Future of AI Art and Artistic Freedom
The final paragraph contemplates the future of AI in the art industry, reflecting on the initial hopes that AI could assist with mundane tasks and protect artists' copyrights. It expresses a shift in sentiment due to recent developments that have artists fearing for their creative autonomy and the potential misuse of their work. The script suggests proactive measures such as using 'glaze' and 'Nightshade', taking multiple photos of artwork, and sharing information about these tools within the community. It concludes with a call for community engagement and a personal invitation for viewers to participate in a survey for a potential group trip to Japan, indicating a desire for connection and collaboration amidst the AI art debate.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡AI Art
💡Mid Journey Ai
💡Animation Studios
💡AI Prompters
💡Meta's Data Scraping
💡Cara App
💡Adobe Terms of Service
💡Glaze and Nightshade
💡AI Data Crawling
💡Artistic Originality
💡Copyright Protection
Highlights
Disney celebrates Thanksgiving with AI art, raising questions about the role of AI in the art industry.
AI art is trained on a dataset of over 16,000 artists, including a 6-year-old child, to mimic real art styles.
Major companies and prestigious animation schools are caught using AI art, sparking controversy in the art community.
AI art's impact on the job market for artists, with studios experiencing layoffs and project cancellations.
An art director's experience with AI art, revealing its limitations in fixing basic mistakes and meeting creative expectations.
Meta's new policy allows them to use all posted content to feed their AI models, raising concerns about artist's rights.
The emergence of the Cara app, a social media platform that doesn't use art for AI training, as an alternative to Instagram.
Adobe's updated terms of service, granting them a license to use customer content for AI training, causing backlash from the art community.
Squarespace's feature allowing users to opt out of AI data crawling, protecting their artwork from being used in AI models.
The introduction of tools like Glaze and Nightshade, designed to protect artists' work from AI mimicry and data theft.
Glaze creates minimal changes to artwork that are indistinguishable to the human eye but different to AI models.
Nightshade aims to poison AI models' output by distorting features, making AI-generated art inaccurate.
The process of using Glaze and Nightshade to protect artwork, including intensity levels and render quality.
The potential of Glaze and Nightshade to disrupt large companies that use AI to steal artists' work without consent.
The debate over whether smaller artists should use Glaze and Nightshade to protect their work from AI theft.
The artist's personal decision to start using Glaze and Nightshade on their artwork posted on social media.
The ongoing discussion about the effectiveness of Glaze and Nightshade against evolving AI models and potential workarounds.
The artist's hope for new laws and legislation to protect artists' rights in the face of AI art advancements.