Midjourney V6 vs DALLE-3 Text Prompt COMPARISON (Print on Demand Ai Art Faceoff)

Philip Anders
22 Dec 202319:19

TLDRThe video script presents a detailed comparison between two graphic design tools, Mid Journey V6 and D E3, based on their performance in nine different prompts. The evaluation criteria include graphic quality, adherence to the prompt, and spelling accuracy in the images. The video showcases the results side by side, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each tool. Mid Journey V6 is praised for its artistic style and vibrant colors, while D E3 is commended for its closer adherence to prompts and better text accuracy. The comparison is designed to help viewers make an informed decision on which tool might be better suited for their graphic design needs, especially for print-on-demand applications. The video encourages viewers to score each round and share their preferences in the comments.

Takeaways

  • 📊 The video is a comparison between two graphic design tools, Mid Journey V6 and D E3, based on their performance with print-on-demand graphics.
  • 🎨 Both tools were tested with the same prompts to evaluate the quality of their graphics, suitability for print-on-demand, and accuracy of text spelling.
  • 🏆 D E3 was found to follow prompts more closely in terms of style and text accuracy, making it slightly more suitable for print-on-demand purposes.
  • 🖌️ Mid Journey V6 produced more artistic and detailed graphics, but sometimes at the expense of text readability and prompt adherence.
  • 🔍 The comparison involved nine different prompts, with the results being visually presented side by side for evaluation.
  • 📝 Text spelling issues were noted for both tools, with D E3 generally performing better in this aspect.
  • 🎉 The video encourages viewers to keep their own score and share their preferences in the comments.
  • 🚀 Despite some shortcomings, both Mid Journey and D E3 have their strengths and can be effective for generating AI graphics.
  • 🌐 The video creator also provides a guide on how to use Mid Journey V6 for those interested in exploring its capabilities further.
  • 💡 The final verdict from the video creator is a slight preference for D E3, but emphasizes that personal preference and use case should guide the choice of tool.

Q & A

  • What was the main purpose of the face-off between Mid Journey V6 and D E3?

    -The main purpose of the face-off was to compare the performance of Mid Journey V6 and D E3 in terms of graphic quality, suitability for print-on-demand, and accuracy of text spelling in the images generated based on various prompts.

  • How was the face-off conducted?

    -The face-off was conducted by giving both Mid Journey and D E3 the same prompt, running it multiple times, and then selecting the top two results from each tool. These results were imported into illustrator and compared side by side.

  • What were the evaluation criteria for the graphics?

    -The evaluation criteria for the graphics included the quality of the graphics, how well they were suited for print-on-demand, and the accuracy of the text spelling in the images.

  • What was the first prompt used in the face-off?

    -The first prompt used was for a cartoon-style image with various types of cheese characters and the phrase 'cheese the day, carp brium', with the cheeses depicted in a lively playful manner on a wide isolated background.

  • How did Mid Journey and D E3 perform with the first prompt?

    -Mid Journey preferred a more artistic style but did not follow the cartoon prompt closely, while D E3 stayed closer to the prompt, resulting in more joyful and playful cheese characters. However, both tools had issues with accurately spelling the phrase 'cheese the day, carp brium'.

  • What was the general observation about Mid Journey's text spelling?

    -It was observed that Mid Journey often made text smaller and harder to read, and sometimes did not spell the text correctly.

  • What was the observation about D E3's text spelling?

    -D E3 generally did a better job with text spelling, getting it correct in most cases. However, it sometimes included unintended text or elements that were not part of the prompt.

  • Which tool was considered more suitable for print-on-demand based on the face-off?

    -Based on the face-off, D E3 was considered slightly more suitable for print-on-demand due to its more accurate text spelling and simpler, less detailed graphics that are easier to work with.

  • What was the final verdict of the face-off?

    -The final verdict was that D E3 won the face-off by a narrow margin, with a score of 5 to 4, due to its better performance in text spelling and suitability for print-on-demand designs.

  • What was the advice given to users about using Mid Journey and D E3?

    -The advice given was that while D E3 might be slightly more suitable for print-on-demand, Mid Journey can still be used effectively, especially for quickly generating a lot of graphics. Users should consider their specific needs and preferences when choosing between the two tools.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 Graphic Design Showdown: Mid Journey V6 vs D E3

The paragraph discusses a face-off between two graphic design tools, Mid Journey V6 and D E3, based on their ability to generate graphics for print-on-demand. The comparison involves nine different prompts, focusing on the quality of the graphics, suitability for print, and accuracy of text spelling. The author shares the results by displaying the top two outputs from each tool side by side in Adobe Illustrator. The first prompt involves creating a cartoon-style image with cheese characters, and the results are critiqued based on adherence to the prompt, color usage, and text accuracy. The verdict for this round is given to D E3 for better following of the prompt and correct spelling.

05:00

🥇 Mid Journey vs D E3: Round 2 & 3 Analysis

The second and third rounds of the graphic design comparison are analyzed. Round two features a 2D flat design of a koala lifting a dumbbell, while round three introduces a stylish girl with a messy bun. The critique focuses on the accuracy of the design to the prompts, text spelling, and overall aesthetics. The author appreciates the detailed and artistic style of Mid Journey but notes its tendency to misspell or shrink text. D E3 is praised for its correct spelling and suitable design for print-on-demand, leading to a win for D E3 in round three.

10:01

🍕 Mid Journey vs D E3: Rounds Four to Six

Rounds four to six of the graphic design face-off are discussed, with prompts ranging from a simple pizza and beer design to a vintage owl illustration. The author evaluates the cartoonish style, vintage effect, and text layout of the outputs. Despite Mid Journey's artistic advantage, D E3 is favored for its adherence to the prompts, correct spelling, and suitability for print-on-demand. The rounds result in a draw, with each tool winning some and losing others.

15:02

🌊 Mid Journey vs D E3: The Decisive Finale

The final round of the graphic design comparison involves creating a vintage distressed graphic of a surfboard. The author examines the interpretation of the prompt, text accuracy, and aesthetic appeal of the designs. While Mid Journey offers a more detailed and less simplistic design, D E3's output is deemed more suitable for print-on-demand due to its style and ease of background removal. The author concludes that D E3 slightly edges out Mid Journey in this comparison, but encourages viewers to share their own scoring and preferences.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Face Off

The term 'Face Off' refers to a competition or comparison between two entities, in this case, two AI tools. In the video, it is used to describe the direct comparison of the performance of Mid Journey V6 and D E3 in generating graphics based on specific prompts. The results are evaluated based on various criteria such as the quality of graphics, adherence to the prompt, and accuracy of text spelling.

💡Graphics

In the context of the video, 'graphics' refers to visual representations or images created by the AI tools. These graphics are evaluated for their suitability for print-on-demand products, such as t-shirts. The term encompasses the artistic style, color scheme, and overall visual appeal of the generated images.

💡Print-on-Demand

Print-on-demand is a production method where products, such as clothing, are manufactured and customized only when an order is received. This concept is central to the video, as the AI-generated graphics are assessed based on their effectiveness and appeal for this specific application.

💡Prompts

In the context of the video, 'prompts' are the specific instructions or descriptions given to the AI tools to generate the desired graphics. These prompts guide the AI in creating images that match the intended theme, style, and content.

💡Text Spelling

The term 'text spelling' refers to the accuracy with which the AI tools render the written words within the generated graphics. This is an important aspect of the evaluation, as incorrect spelling can negatively impact the usability of the graphics, especially in a print-on-demand context.

💡Illustrator

In this context, 'Illustrator' refers to a software application used for creating and editing vector graphics. The speaker mentions using Illustrator to import and compare the graphics generated by the AI tools, side by side, to evaluate their quality and accuracy.

💡Cartoon Style

The term 'cartoon style' describes a visual art form characterized by exaggerated features and simplified shapes, often used to create a lighthearted or humorous effect. In the video, it is one of the stylistic elements mentioned in the prompts given to the AI tools, and the speaker evaluates how well each tool captures this style in their graphics.

💡Vapor Wave

Vapor Wave is a term that refers to both a music genre and an aesthetic style that emerged in the 2010s. In visual art, it is characterized by the use of pastel colors, retro elements, and a dreamy, nostalgic vibe. The video mentions a prompt for a 'vapor wave themed t-shirt design', indicating that the AI tools were tested on their ability to capture this specific and popular aesthetic.

💡Typography

Typography is the art and technique of arranging typefaces and organizing text in a visually appealing and legible manner. In the video, it is a critical aspect of the design prompts, with the AI tools being assessed on their ability to create graphics that incorporate the specified typography styles, such as 'rough distressed font'.

💡Vintage

The term 'vintage' refers to something that is of high quality and from an earlier period, often associated with a classic or timeless appeal. In the context of the video, it describes a design style that the AI tools are tasked with replicating, characterized by aged or retro elements.

Highlights

Comparison of AI graphic generators Mid Journey V6 and D E3 based on 9 different prompts.

Evaluation criteria include graphic quality, suitability for print-on-demand, and accuracy of text spelling.

Mid Journey's artistic style deviates from the cartoon prompt but offers vibrant colors and a lively vibe.

D E3 adheres more closely to the prompts, delivering results that are more playful and joyful as requested.

In the cheese-themed graphic, Mid Journey struggles with spelling accuracy, while D E3 performs better.

For the 2D flat design prompt featuring a koala, Mid Journey provides a detailed and less flat graphic, whereas D E3 offers a more stylized and correct spelling.

In the stylish girl design, Mid Journey's text spelling is inaccurate, while D E3 nails the phrase with correct spelling and layout.

The pizza and beer graphic sees Mid Journey's cartoon style outperforming D E3's simplistic approach in terms of visual appeal.

D E3 struggles with spelling in the pizza and beer prompt, but its style is more suitable for print-on-demand.

Mid Journey's vintage sunset theme in the owl graphic offers a more textured and old-fashioned effect.

D E3's colorful and symmetrical design in the owl graphic is easier to work with for background removal.

In the vapor wave raccoon design, D E3's simpler and more suitable style for print-on-demand stands out.

The avocado graphic from D E3 is more realistic and suitable for print, with better text readability.

Good Vibes typography design from Mid Journey offers a cool distressed look and better readability.

D E3's Good Vibes design, while visually appealing, is harder to read and less ideal for print-on-demand.

The final round's vintage distressed surfboard graphic from D E3 is more in line with typical print-on-demand designs.

Overall, D E3 is slightly more suitable for print-on-demand, but Mid Journey has its strengths in speed and variety.