AI Art Generator Comparison: Midjourney V5 (Paid) vs. Blue Willow (Free)

Curtis Pyke
11 Apr 202307:35

TLDRIn this video, the creator compares two AI image generators: the paid Mid-Journey and the free Blue Willow. By running five random prompts through each platform, the video showcases the results, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of both. Mid-Journey excels in creating detailed, dreamy landscapes and sharp, futuristic cityscapes, while Blue Willow impresses with its realistic portraits and believable rugged coastlines. The comparison aims to help viewers make an informed choice based on their needs and budget.

Takeaways

  • 🎨 The video is a comparison between two AI art generators: the paid Mid-Journey and the free Blue Willow.
  • 🆓 Mid-Journey used to offer 25 free images but now operates on a paid model only.
  • 🤖 Chat GPT was used to generate five random detailed prompts for AI image and art generation, including photography and art examples.
  • 🌄 The first prompt was to create a serene landscape photograph of a misty mountain range at sunrise, with both generators producing quality results, but Mid-Journey's output was deemed superior.
  • 🏙️ The second prompt requested a digital painting of a futuristic cityscape with advanced technology, where Mid-Journey's output was more aligned with the prompt's requirements.
  • 🖼️ The third prompt was for a black and white portrait photograph capturing raw emotion and vulnerability, where Blue Willow surprised with an outstanding result, though Mid-Journey was still favored.
  • 🎨 The fourth prompt asked for a mixed media artwork with a whimsical theme, and Mid-Journey's response was more in line with the prompt.
  • 🏞️ The final prompt generated a landscape photograph of rugged coastlines, with Blue Willow's result being preferred for its realism.
  • 📈 The comparison showed that while Mid-Journey generally had an edge, Blue Willow produced some exceptional and usable art, especially considering it's free.
  • 💡 The video emphasizes the value of both AI art generators, suggesting that users can make informed choices based on their needs and budget.
  • 🙌 The creator encourages viewers to reach out for further information and promises to return with more content soon.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video?

    -The main topic of the video is a comparison between two AI image generators: the free Blue Willow and the paid Mid Journey.

  • How does the video creator obtain the prompts for the AI image generation?

    -The video creator uses Chat GPT as a random prompt generator to obtain five detailed prompts for AI image and art generation.

  • What was the first prompt used in the comparison?

    -The first prompt was to generate a landscape photograph capturing the serene beauty of a misty mountain range at sunrise, conveying a sense of calmness and tranquility.

  • How does the video creator evaluate the results from the AI image generators?

    -The video creator evaluates the results by comparing the images produced by both AI generators based on their adherence to the prompts, quality, and artistic effects.

  • Which AI generator performed better for the first prompt?

    -For the first prompt, Mid Journey performed better as it produced an image that closely matched the prompt's requirements for a dreamy, ethereal effect.

  • What was the second prompt and how did the AI generators handle it?

    -The second prompt was to create a digital painting of an otherworldly cityscape with futuristic technology and vivid colors. Both AI generators produced interesting results, with Mid Journey offering a more sci-fi look and Blue Willow providing a more abstract art style.

  • Which AI generator surprised the video creator for the third prompt?

    -Blue Willow surprised the video creator for the third prompt, which was to create a portrait photograph capturing raw emotion and vulnerability in black and white.

  • What was the fourth prompt and which AI generator did the video creator prefer?

    -The fourth prompt was to create a mixed media artwork with a whimsical, playful theme. The video creator preferred Mid Journey's interpretation of the prompt over Blue Willow's.

  • How did the video creator conclude the comparison?

    -The video creator concluded that while Mid Journey has an edge in some prompts due to its paid nature, Blue Willow offered fantastic results for a free AI image generator, and both were usable in many cases.

  • What was the final prompt and which AI generator received the advantage?

    -The final prompt was to generate a landscape photograph of rugged coastlines. The video creator gave the advantage to Blue Willow for this prompt, as it closely resembled a believable landscape.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 AI Art Generation Comparison: Mid-Journey vs Blue Willow

This paragraph introduces a video tutorial comparing two AI art generators: the free Blue Willow and the paid Mid-Journey. The comparison is based on randomly generated prompts using chat GPT, which includes photography and art examples. The video creator has purchased Mid-Journey and has access to the Blue Willow bot. The aim is to evaluate both platforms based on their ability to generate AI images and art from the prompts.

05:00

🏞️ Landscape and Cityscape Art Generation

This paragraph discusses the results of the first two prompts generated by chat GPT. The first prompt was to create a serene landscape photograph of a misty mountain range at sunrise, and the second was to generate a digital painting of a futuristic cityscape. The video creator evaluates the outputs from both AI generators, comparing their quality, adherence to the prompt, and overall visual appeal. Mid-Journey is praised for its dreamy, ethereal landscape, while Blue Willow's cityscape is noted for its abstract art style and usability.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡AI image generator

An AI image generator is a software application that uses artificial intelligence to create images based on user inputs. In the context of the video, it refers to the main focus of the tutorial, which is comparing two different AI image generators: Blue Willow and Mid-Journey.

💡Free vs. Paid

The terms 'free' and 'paid' refer to the pricing models of the AI image generators being discussed. Free models do not require payment for usage, while paid models require a financial investment to access their services. The video evaluates the differences in quality and features between a free AI generator (Blue Willow) and a paid one (Mid-Journey).

💡Random prompt generator

A random prompt generator is a tool or system that creates unpredictable or arbitrary text inputs or ideas to inspire or guide creative processes. In the video, it is used to obtain unbiased and varied inputs for testing the image-generating capabilities of both AI systems.

💡Mid-Journey

Mid-Journey is a paid AI image generator platform mentioned in the video. It was known for offering a certain number of free images but has since transitioned to a fully paid model. The video discusses its features and compares its image generation quality with that of Blue Willow.

💡Blue Willow

Blue Willow is a free AI image generator platform that is being compared to Mid-Journey in the video. It is noted for its ability to generate images based on user prompts without any cost, and its performance is evaluated against a paid alternative.

💡Landscape photograph

A landscape photograph is a type of image that captures the visible features of an area, typically a wide and scenic view. In the video, it is one of the types of images that the AI generators are tasked to create, with specific characteristics such as serenity and tranquility at sunrise.

💡Digital painting

A digital painting is an artwork created using digital tools and software, often模仿ulating the appearance of traditional painting techniques. In the context of the video, it is one of the art forms that the AI generators are prompted to produce, with a requirement for a futuristic cityscape.

💡Portrait photograph

A portrait photograph is a type of image that focuses on capturing the face and expressions of an individual or group. The video discusses the creation of portrait photographs by AI, emphasizing the capture of raw emotions and vulnerability in black and white.

💡Mixed media artwork

Mixed media artwork refers to a type of art that combines various artistic media and techniques in a single piece. The video includes a prompt for the AI generators to create a mixed media artwork with a whimsical theme, incorporating different textures and materials like watercolor, colored pencils, and digital brushes.

💡Comparison

In the context of the video, a comparison involves evaluating and contrasting the outputs of two different AI image generators, Blue Willow and Mid-Journey, based on their ability to generate images from given prompts. The comparison aims to help viewers understand the strengths and weaknesses of each platform.

💡User experience

User experience refers to the overall satisfaction and ease of use that a person has when interacting with a system or service. In the video, the user experience is discussed in relation to how the AI generators handle the prompts and the quality of the resulting images.

Highlights

The comparison is between two AI image generators: the free Blue Willow and the paid Mid-Journey.

Mid-Journey was previously offering 25 free images but has since transitioned to a fully paid model.

The tutorial uses a random prompt generator with Chat GPT to create five detailed prompts for AI image and art generation.

The first prompt involves generating a landscape photograph of a misty mountain range at sunrise, aiming for a serene and dreamy effect.

Mid-Journey's response to the first prompt is praised for its soft muted colors and warm soft lighting, effectively capturing the desired mood.

Blue Willow's output for the first prompt is considered usable, but lacks the same level of dreaminess and softness as Mid-Journey's.

The second prompt requests a digital painting of a futuristic cityscape with advanced technology and vivid colors.

Mid-Journey's second prompt results are described as Blade Runner-esque with high contrast and vivid colors, meeting the expectations set by the prompt.

Blue Willow's take on the second prompt is noted for its abstract art look, differing from Mid-Journey's more realistic approach.

The third prompt calls for a black and white portrait photograph capturing raw emotion and vulnerability.

Mid-Journey excels in translating the third prompt into a photographic standard, creating images that appear very realistic.

Surprisingly, Blue Willow's output for the third prompt is considered exceptional for a free tool, producing images that look like real photographs.

The fourth prompt asks for a mixed media artwork with a whimsical theme, incorporating various textures and materials.

Mid-Journey's response to the fourth prompt showcases a blend of watercolor, colored pencils, and digital brushes, effectively meeting the prompt's requirements.

Blue Willow's interpretation of the fourth prompt is different, focusing more on hard drawings rather than the mixed media style requested.

The final prompt is for a landscape photograph of rugged coastlines, with both AI tools producing believable results.

In the final comparison, Blue Willow is given the edge for its realistic depiction of a coastline, similar to the speaker's personal surroundings.

The video concludes with a summary that Blue Willow is a fantastic free option, while Mid-Journey remains a strong choice as a paid service.