🔥 Did I Rank With HarborSEO? Tried and Tested..
TLDRIn this video, Vlad reviews Harbor SEO, a tool aimed at improving SEO rankings. He compares it with other popular AI writers, focusing on output quality, ranking performance, and technical issues. Harbor SEO currently ranks 6th in Vlad's AI writer directory, showing potential but still lacking certain optimization features found in competitors. Despite its technical issues and lower humanization score, Vlad was able to rank an article using Harbor SEO. He highlights its unique features, like infographics and keyword suggestions, but notes the need for further improvements.
Takeaways
- 🔥 HarborSEO is currently ranked sixth among seven AI writers, but it's still a work in progress.
- 😊 Vlad emphasizes that his review is objective and based on specific criteria, not personal bias.
- ⚙️ HarborSEO struggles with SEO optimization and humanized text output, scoring lower than competitors like QuillBot and Agility Writer.
- 📝 Vlad generated an article with a 49 SEO score, which improved slightly after adjusting the H1 title.
- 💡 The readability score of the generated content ranges from grade 7 to grade 10, which is considered passable.
- 🤔 Despite some technical issues with HarborSEO, like missing internal links and diagrams, Vlad recognizes its potential.
- 📊 HarborSEO is the only AI writer in the review that supports infographics and includes a unique keyword research tool.
- 🎯 While Vlad was able to rank with HarborSEO for a recent article, he stresses that rankings alone don't prove an AI writer’s effectiveness.
- 🧠 Vlad believes that true SEO success depends on retaining rankings, not just achieving them quickly.
- 📈 Vlad concludes that HarborSEO performs well for its early stage but has room for improvement, particularly in SEO capabilities.
Q & A
What is the purpose of the video review on HarborSEO?
-The purpose of the video review is to test and share the overall ranking of HarborSEO among other AI writers, discuss its output quality, share personal impressions, and answer whether the reviewer was able to rank with HarborSEO.
What is the current ranking of HarborSEO according to the video?
-In the video, HarborSEO is currently occupying the sixth spot in the ranking among other AI writers.
What are the unique features of HarborSEO mentioned in the review?
-HarborSEO is highlighted for its ability to produce infographics and its keyword research capabilities.
What is the reviewer's personal opinion on HarborSEO's output quality?
-The reviewer thinks HarborSEO is an amazing product but has faced technical issues such as incorrect internal links and missing diagrams or infographics when pasting into HTML.
What is the reviewer's stance on using AI writers for content ranking?
-The reviewer believes that ranking is not proof enough that an AI writer works, and it's more about retaining the rankings rather than just achieving them.
How does the reviewer measure the quality of AI-generated content?
-The reviewer measures the quality of AI-generated content through SEO scores, readability, human-like action scores, and user reviews.
What is the reviewer's process for testing the effectiveness of AI writers?
-The reviewer tests the effectiveness of AI writers by generating articles based on specific keywords, checking the SEO scores, readability, and action scores, and observing whether the content ranks in search results.
What is the final score given to HarborSEO by the reviewer?
-The final score given to HarborSEO by the reviewer is around three out of five.
What is the significance of the keyword 'AI humanizer tools for academic writing' in the review?
-The keyword 'AI humanizer tools for academic writing' is significant because it was suggested by HarborSEO and used to create an article that ranked well in search results.
What is the reviewer's advice for getting an article sample from HarborSEO?
-The reviewer advises signing up for the newsletter to get an article sample and mentions that it will also include access to Outline Genius GBD.
What is the reviewer's view on the importance of infographics in content?
-The reviewer views infographics as a valuable feature, noting that HarborSEO is one of the few AI writers that can produce them.
Outlines
📊 Harbor SEO Review and Ranking Insights
The speaker, Vlad, introduces a review of Harbor SEO, an AI writer tool, and discusses its current ranking among seven other AI writers. He mentions that Harbor SEO is in the sixth position based on objective criteria, despite being a work in progress with ongoing updates. Vlad shares his personal impressions, highlighting the tool's output quality, and notes that it has a 49 SEO score, a readability grade of 10, and a high action score indicating human-like content. He also discusses the tool's limitations in SEO optimization compared to other tools and mentions that user reviews on YouTube give it a score closer to 4 out of 5. Vlad concludes by sharing his personal positive experience with Harbor SEO, despite occasional technical issues, and demonstrates how he was able to rank with the tool by creating an article that suggested a keyword and discussing the importance of retaining rankings over just achieving them.
🔍 Detailed Analysis of Harbor SEO's Performance
In this paragraph, Vlad delves deeper into Harbor SEO's performance, discussing the technical issues he faced, such as broken internal links and missing infographics. He acknowledges that Harbor SEO is a work in progress and that such issues are expected. Vlad emphasizes that his ranking assessment is based on specific criteria and is not influenced by his personal experiences with the tool. He then shares his success in ranking with Harbor SEO, using a keyword suggested by the tool itself to create an article that did rank well. However, he also points out that not all articles created with Harbor SEO rank, indicating the complexity of assessing an AI writer's quality based solely on rankings. Vlad concludes by encouraging viewers to check out Harbor SEO, subscribe to his newsletter for article samples, and appreciates his audience's support.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Harbor SEO
💡AI Writer
💡SEO Score
💡Readability
💡Humanization Score
💡Keyword Research
💡Infographics
💡Content Generation
💡Ranking
💡AI Detection
Highlights
Introduction to Harbor SEO and the purpose of the review: evaluating its ranking and SEO capabilities.
Harbor SEO currently ranks 6th among seven other AI writers in the directory.
The AI writer lacks full SEO optimization features but allows the insertion of keywords.
Harbor SEO's readability score improved from grade 10 to grade 7 after adjusting the title.
The human action score of Harbor SEO is only 15%, indicating a high AI content presence.
Despite the technical issues, Harbor SEO offers features like infographics and HTML table generation.
The tool is still under active development, with constant updates being rolled out.
Harbor SEO's technical issues include internal links pointing to non-existent articles and HTML paste errors.
The overall score for Harbor SEO improved to 3.1 out of 5 after some updates.
The lack of SEO-optimized features like one-click optimization places it below other tools like QuillBot and Jasper.
User-generated articles ranked on Google, despite technical challenges.
Harbor SEO generated a relevant keyword ('Top 5 AI Humanizer Tools for Academic Writing') that helped achieve a third-place ranking.
The reviewer highlights that ranking success is not a reliable measure of an AI writer's long-term SEO effectiveness.
User reviews show an average score of 3.9 on YouTube, with no Reddit discussions available.
The conclusion emphasizes the need for objective experiments with multiple AI writers to assess their ranking performance.